OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
61134076 over 7 years ago

Moving Le desert from France to Australia is not on.

60102631 over 7 years ago

Before you changed is way/388771229/ it rendered correctly with landcover=scrub and natural=scrub!!! And I believe that the change you made there is yet to be processed ..

The problem here is apparently man_made=clearcut.

You will note this is not rendering correctly at the moment as the changes you have made are still to be processed. We will wait and see if this renders correctly without the man_made tag. And then reintroduce the landcover tag and see if that truly makes a difference? I note that the at least some of the other ways with landcover and natural=scrub continue to be correctly rendered. I have not looked at all of them.

OSM looks to be a bit busy at the moment... so lets leave it for 2 days and see what happens.

61082732 over 7 years ago

This rendered correctly before you remove the landcover tag.

61049149 over 7 years ago

Interiors are dealt with by declaring a multipolygon relation - the outer way is placed into the relation with the role 'outer'. Then the way for the inner is placed into the relation with the role 'inner'. You can have more than one inner, and more than one outer. The relation carries the tags, not the outer way nor the inner. An inner could have different tags - e.g. a playground.

Best to find you an example?
Arr here you go relation/4111231#map=18/-41.06006/145.87981
That should help.

61049149 over 7 years ago

Oh the pitches you have marked as basket ball .. one is netball - different court markings. I have corrected this. There are a few other pitches to map here too.

61049149 over 7 years ago

Hi,
There are some problems with Way: 610735693 - building = school.

First as a single building .. it crosses itself. That is not on.

Second there is a conflict between the building and a road already in OSM

Third .. using bing .. it is not a single building .. but at least 5 separate buildings. Possibly 7.

Note - some buildings connect by covered walkways and these can confuse the issue. Similar comments on multiple buildings for some of the other additions.

In short .. needs work. You may find DigitalGlobe Standard Imagery better.

61047619 over 7 years ago

If you look at way/388771229/
you can see it now renders. It did not render before the tag change.

I have commented at length on changeset/60102631. Further comments can be made there.

60102631 over 7 years ago

Note
natural=scrub look like it renders
see way/180492080#map=16/51.1315/-3.2225

man_made=clearcut looks like it does not render see way/412607126

60102631 over 7 years ago

Tagging for the render? :)

Editors should allow 'any tag you like' as that is an OSM principle.

Natural=scrub is the documented tag on the OSMwiki .. if you search for scrub there you get that page. Natural=scrub has over 1,800,000 uses in the data base, so it should render!
Landuse=scrub is not documented on the OSMwiki. Landuse=scrub has ~1,600 uses in the data base. As a tag I don't think much of it.

I had not realized any render was using landuse=scrub. Possibly the rendering was of man_made=clearcut? And that might be the best tag for it. In principle .. one feature .. one OSM item? So maybe this way would be best tagged with only man_made=clearcut untill it regenerates somewhat?

Humm maybe it is man_made=clearcut that is not rendering? That has only 4,000 uses on the data base.

Why don't you try each tag in turn (and onlly one tag)? See what happens?

Note that it can take some time for a render to note the change in tags.

60102631 over 7 years ago

Hi,
scrub is not a land use .. it is a land cover, that you may tag as natural=scrub.

61012535 over 7 years ago

No.
These are not;
riverbanks
rivers
bridges
fords ...
unclassified highways ...

They are farmers fields.
Tracks

They may have water ways that the farmer has made .. but they are not creeks, streams nor rivers.

And stop using the name tag as a descriptor!!!!

60943906 over 7 years ago

Again .. names are for names only. Not as descriptions. E.g. 'Intermittent Stream', 'Condamine Intermittent River', 'Condamine Riverbank', 'Service Road' etc.

Remove them.
------------------
Living Road ...it is a service road.

The cemetery IS NOT A VILLAGE!!!!! Way: Killarney Cemetery (609862966)

The riverbanks are not a river banks .. the river does not flow through it. Looks like a farmers field .. possibly for growing rice? Or is it a water storage device? See OSM basin. Way: 609862967 Way: 609862969 Way: Condamine Riverbank (609862972)

60947951 over 7 years ago

The Prince of Wales Hospital should be expanded to the buildings and linked to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_of_Wales_Hospital_(Sydney). The landuse should be removed .. that is on a much larger area.
The river .. is not a river . that looks like an ovderflow or channel used by a farmer to get water. In either case a river.
The pitch .. most pitches are rectangular, and are marked for the sport played. What sport is played here? Looks like a farmers field to me. Possibly a park?

60930936 over 7 years ago

Sorry, yes I corrected it. But wanted to pass the information on to avoid repeats.

Keep mapping, there is heaps to do.

60941006 over 7 years ago

name=Old Smoke ... but what is it?
barrier=Old Smake .. what kind of barrier???

60941006 over 7 years ago

Inappropriate change set comment. Again.

Your Swamp DropDown is not a swamp. It could be a storm water drain ... Swamps are drawn as an area.

the Coogee SLSC is already on a building there is no need for it to be on a node. And this node now distorts the building.

Multiple nodes and ways for Russel Jones Memorial pool Why?

60930936 over 7 years ago

Hi,
Welcome to OSM and thanks for your contribution.

The way/609727892 you introduced for parking is not correct. Ways should not cross themselves .. in this case they need to be separated up into 3 individual ways.

60925503 over 7 years ago

Arrrg.
Enough ...
Dog park deleted.
natural features corrected -they don't go to the center of roads/path

60925503 over 7 years ago

Half the changes you made have already been edited by 2 other mappers!

Hero Sushi is not a simple 'shop' but sells food .. I have retagged it as a restaurant

Deleted 'Randwick city council service road' .. it does not exist as a permanent thing.

60920506 over 7 years ago

a lot, lot that is not right!

1) do not add personal things .. e.g. finish line.
2) do not duplicate what is already in OSM - some of the path is already there.
3) Try finding things on the OSM wiki .. life jacket is hard though .. it is emergency=life_ring .. don't draw a representation of it...
4) Use the LIP Imagery to add details .. the path can be more precisely mapped using it.
5) where a path crosses a road there should be a note with highway=crossing and crossing=uncontrolled/traffic_lights/*

----------------
If you look on the map you will find a path you did not use - 'Eastern Beaches Coastal Walk (undercliff)' .... would have saved some street walking.