Tomas Straupis's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | „Outsider“ (as you put it) is not providing anything we need (we need current data, not historical one; current translations to a lot of languages for placenames can easily come from wikipedia/wikidata which we already have, so adding them is redundant even more than name:lt tag is).
|
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | As wmyrda has pointed out, he is taking a map from 1928-1939 and trying to map what he sees there to todays villages. Both mapping such different things as well as putting names from that map is incorrect. If his purpose is solely to use that old map to get Polish names - then he is using bad source. If he wants to put information of that historical map to some GIS DB (in this case OSM), then he is putting data into wrong place because that data will divert from his hard work really fast.
|
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | And main point. Please respect a strive of Lithuanian mappers for as higher quality as possible and not look at it as "it's your choice, so you fix what we brake".
|
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | 1. Yes, there is only one official language in Lithuania - Lithuanian (85% of population are Lithuanians, so there is no point of having other official language).
|
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | 1. You're doing work which belongs to OpenHistoricalMap, not OpenStreetMap. This explains why some of the name:pl tags you add are incorrect: they have nothing in common with official name, neither phonetically, nor by the meaning. While I'm not interested in name:pl tags, expect those to be fixed by other mappers.
|
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | @rmikke:
|
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | Keepright or no, this is almost ten years old rule how name:* tags work. Keepright is just one of QA tools which checks it.
|
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | OSM spirit says that you must consult and take into account the local mapping rules. Local mapping rules in Lithuania is to do QUALITY work, not anything anyway someway anyhow. You KNOW the rules, you know what you must do, it is not hard to do that, and yet you say you will do it in incorrect way. How do you expect such behaviour to be valued? |
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | In Lithuania ALL values in name tag are Lithuanian. So if the point you're changing is in Lithuania, name tag HAS Lithuanian value.
|
| 46626085 | almost 9 years ago | Chrm. You're updating not 10-20, but hundreds objects and I have to spend too much time fixing it. It is not nice, that you're knowingly introducing a lot of errors. Please fix your automated script if you want to do more automated updates. The rule is very simple: if area is in Lithuania and name:lt does not exist, add name:lt with value equal to name value. Thank you. |
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | I probable have never changed any placename with old_name tag. But if I do, I will only change name tag and leave old_name (and old_name:pl) as is. |
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | OK. But just for your information: in Lithuania all place names and population are checked/compared to official placename registry (new placenames appear, old ones disappear monthly). So in Lithuania all placenames have name tag in Lithuanian. |
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | Fixing errors which different QA tools (including keepright.at) finds.
|
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | This was one of keepright.at checks from looong time ago... |
| 46469488 | almost 9 years ago | Please add name:lt with value equal to name when adding other name:* tags (one of keepright.at errors). Thank you. |
| 46461226 | almost 9 years ago | Na, jei tikrai taip yra, tada gerai. Nes, kiek rašė OsmAnd naudotojai, jiems POI reikia ANT kelio. |
| 46461226 | almost 9 years ago | Bet ar į tą šalia kelio esančią kamerą, kuri niekaip nesujungta su keliu, reaguoja (parodo įspėjimą apie kamerą) nors vienas maršrutizatorius? Mano žiniomis ne, bet aš į kamerų žymėjimą per daug nesigilinau, tai galiu klysti. |
| 46461226 | almost 9 years ago | Ar tikrai gerai pašalinta kamera? Nes išimta iš kelio, todėl maršrutizatoriai nebežinos apie šitą kamerą. |
| 46441132 | almost 9 years ago | Pakeitimas atšauktas. Namo pozicija yra ten, kur yra namo pagrindas, o ne kur ortofotografijoje matosi stogas. |
| 46221460 | almost 9 years ago | Reverted |