> "I think information provided by the proprietor may be transformed into tagging"

Yes, as said, that should be fine as these are individual data and not structured collections. (Probably our messages crossed.)

Assumptions, 90% probable. That's the Google approach.
OSM want to catch the 10% exceptions, ground verified.

@ti-lo, as said in another comment, snappy remarks don't help.
Nakaner and I were talking about business directories providing structured listings. I.e. facts that somebody else has collected in such way.
An individual address from an individual homepage should be fine, in particular if you also add the website that proves the source.

I'm just keen on keeping OSM data to comply with its own license.
Thanks for sharing the link, certainly thing will change in future. Please consider that the _existence_ of OSM, by legally surveying data, has contributed a lot to governments opening their geo-data nowadays.

That is plausible, thanks.

According to OSM rules:
osm.wiki/Copyright
Another reason not to copy from business listings is that they contain an awful amount of outdated information, which we don't want to be copied into OSM.
In general, snappy comments do not help to resolve issues.

Yes I have seen they advertise quads on their website. but as you are armchair mapping, how would you know that they not also sell 2-wheel bikes locally?

Since you were removing the shop=motorcycle, how did you verify that the shop does _not_ sell motorcycles, beside the quads?

The value 'atv' is poorly chosen, as the acronym is not obvious for anybody not into quad cycling.
(The wiki page shop=atv was created by yourself earlier this year as wiki user Rtfm)

You must not copy data from other databases and business directories without explicit permission.

What is the source of the business details you added? Have you been there? Or is it from Yellow pages as in changeset/52600487 ?

Does this mean you have added address, opening hours, brands being sold, and other business details from a "Yellow pages" business directory?
https://www.pagesjaunes.fr/pros/00100703
First, this violates the copyright of the other database, and you are copying data that are not ODbL-compliant into OSM.
Second, this constitutes an import in which you have not individually verified the data, thus decreasing the OSM data quality.

Repaired

Repaired

Repaired.

Thanks.

landuse sollte nicht auf einer einzelnen Node verwendet werden. Dein erster Ansatz, die Gegenden mit place=neighbourhood zu benennen, war plausibler.
Repariert.
Heisst wirklich das Wohnviertel "Am Haus Borg", oder ist das nur der dort ohnehin vorhandene Straßenname?

Ja das muss weitergehend diskutiert werde, ich wollte nur erstmal deine Meinung hören.
Die Diskussion auf der Tagging-Liste ist bereits im Gang: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/2017-September/033439.html

Hi ulrichm, I have seen lots of objects in Tunesia that have the tag addr:continent=Africa, which is not part of the address scheme.
addr:country ist the highest element.
It would be good if you could help checking the addresses and removing the tag in your area.
http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/rKg

natural=sand für die Sandfläche ist gut.
Wenn das der Buddelkasten eines Spielplatzes ist, kannst du gern auch
playground=sandpit
hinzufügen :-)
Danke.