Mundilfari's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 106673334 | over 4 years ago | Did you actually check the NSI link? Or review the wikidata item? Q41171672 is being used with both, brand=ALDI and brand=ALDI Süd, based on the country (see NSI link above). In the US, all stores are branded as ALDI (not ALDI Süd). That's what the name and brand tags reflected after my change.
If I decided to open a store tomorrow and call it Walmart, I'm sure you sure wouldn't tag it as Q483551 either... You may be interested in the discussion that led up to the split of the aldi brand in NSI (it wasn't me proposing this split): https://github.com/osmlab/name-suggestion-index/pull/5109 I don't know why ID is using an outdated set of brand presets in this case - my assumption is that it isn't updated from NSI on the fly but only periodically. I'm sure you'll see the updated presets in a couple of days.
Interesting thought on the google/apple pay. They are listed as valid values on the wiki though, and removing them is a loss of information (because, no matter what cc's the store accepts, they may or may not have terminals that are ready & enabled for mobile payments through google pay/apple pay, so I'd argue that removing them without a replacement is a disimprovement). |
| 106678919 | over 4 years ago | Just as with the other changeset I commented on earlier - please don't change aldi stores back to Q125054. This is completely ambiguous.
|
| 106673334 | over 4 years ago | Actually, this is not a correction. Please review the aldi brand tagging under https://nsi.guide/index.html?t=brands&k=shop&v=supermarket&tt=aldi
Aldi (US) is a fully owned subsidiary of Aldi Sud.
Apart from that - any particular reason why you removed some of the payment tags? |
| 104373193 | over 4 years ago | both the oh and paym opt can be verified on the company's website. |
| 104747328 | over 4 years ago | Hi Andy - I saw these, long after they were added, so I decided not to discuss them further. The question that was being asked in the one was related to the usage of a specific tag, which is documented in the wiki.
|
| 98031717 | almost 5 years ago | review request can be ignored, this was selected inadvertently. |