Mateusz Konieczny's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 119066930 | about 1 month ago | Sadly it is quite hard to say, as I am not experienced with location (I never visited Thailand, and the closest I got was on trip to z Ukraine). Also I have limited experience with jewellery. Though if they sell bracelets/necklaces - even if those are bought as investments - I think considering them as jewellery shops works. It would be maybe trickier if they would be selling primarily gold bars etc |
| 174646008 | about 1 month ago | Edycja wycofana że względu na brak reakcji be komentarze |
| 174980205 | about 1 month ago | There was huge trunk discussion, definition was changed.
Thanks for reminder about English translations! It seems that these pages were not updated - can you post link if you have it handy? (I still try to remember and find it, but if you still have link in browser...) Change should be now reverted so no extra action needed with that |
| 174980205 | about 1 month ago | Why you think that "normal" junctions make trunk impossible? Please, look at highway=trunk in UK. And bad German tagging is irrelevant here, as it is not in Germany. Also, note that trunk retaggings in Poland must be first proposed and discussed at forums. |
| 174948821 | about 1 month ago | Survey, not surgery |
| 174829288 | about 1 month ago | A po twojej zmianie jadąc z północy i zjeżdżając na S52 nagle masz 300 m drogi niższej klasy co jest błędniejsze Dodatkowo: gdzie dyskusja na forum przed zmianą? Nigdy nie rób zmian klasy dróg jak trunk bez dyskusji na forum |
| 172914669 | about 1 month ago | https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/drogi-w-budowie/94470/128 |
| 173646888 | about 1 month ago | a, najwyraźniej tak: widać na zdjęciu |
| 173646888 | about 1 month ago | nie wiem |
| 173646888 | about 1 month ago | I niestety widać efekty: https://dziennikpolski24.pl/wielka-wycinka-w-centrum-bronowic-z-krajobrazu-zniknelo-50-dorodnych-drzew-powstanie-wielki-dworzec-dla-polnocno-zachodniej-czesci-krakowa/ar/c1p2-28176885 |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | and to be clear, this type of confusion would be perfectly fine and not bannable offence if these would be new people but I strongly suspect that these accounts are operated by a single person |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | (are additional listings like that needed or is it enough for now? I prefer to not spend too long on that, unless it would be useful) |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | way/1329312751/history - here it is clearly not highway=trunk Philet2137 is this time basing edit on a different type of official paper, E-road routing for some reason E75 was not moved to A1/S7 and still goes through city center luckily for residents it is not anymore very important road, definitely not on national scale so highway=trunk is extremely dubious - especially with "E75 is there" as sole justification |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | way/339597002/history - Philet2137 and Pan_palat removed ref=5 solely because some official documents supposedly changed it was still signed last time anyone checked it, and they are not even disputing this (just changing stuff with "official paper says otherwise" as sole reason) note: at some point removal of ref=5 may be a valid edit, especially after S3 road is opened, 5 road will be likely actually degraded |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | In general problem here is less with that specific road has some innate primariness and user retagged it to trunk despite it not having trunkiness. Typically it is not about road being discussed and community reaching conclusion. Rather the problem is that some mappers (especially Temat-Droga) refused to discuss anything and tried to force their preferred tagging. In unending parade of new accounts. Or with flood of changes.
So it is more about "totally new account appears, makes changes to from =secondary to =trunk in their first or second edit, continues this kind of editing". @FILszew/history is one just appeared BTW So in "more unexplained undiscussed nonsense trunk category changes" main problem is 'undiscussed' part and it may be overly procedural and it is a bit tricky to provide proof of no discussion except discussion not taking place.
Hopefully this answers a bit why I though "no discussion happened, nothing linked in changeset" is considered as offense in itself? Maybe I am overtouchy and it is perfectly normal newbie edit to fiddle with highway=secondary to highway=trunk on long road distance on the second edit? |
| 174783986 | about 1 month ago | przypominam że takie edycje zmian klasyfikacji dróg powinny być dyskutowane na forum, na https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/pl/40 w przeciwnym razie każdy może je wycofać, bez dalszych powodów |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | (for this specific account and this edit, I remember we have few more accounts) |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | OK, that will take a bit more time. Lets start with way/27597535/history or https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/osm-deep-history/#/way/41189769 problem is not with whether it is secondary or primary but because change was motivated by official road classification while road classes in official classification (either of them) do not match to OSM one, this is documented at osm.wiki/Pl:Key:highway#Warto%C5%9Bci and osm.wiki/Pl:Drogi#Klasyfikacja_dr%C3%B3g this is also listed at osm.wiki/International_highway_classification_equivalence#Examples_of_cases_contradicting_simple_rules disclaimer: I authored that mandatory discussion of changes to high road classes is described and documented for example at osm.wiki/Pl:Znakowanie_dr%C3%B3g_w_Polsce#Drogi_samochodowe A tiny bit ironically added by Pavv in osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Pl:Znakowanie_dr%C3%B3g_w_Polsce&diff=prev&oldid=2919811 very recently there but this is in general supported and was documented somewhere else already (cannot find it right now) -------------------- would this be considered sufficient? |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | I could easily write down more of Temat-Droga class of issues but I hope it is enough |
| 174736769 | about 1 month ago | oh, it is more obnoxious as it is either the same person or multiple people with the same trunk-related obsessions, editing similar roads and pope-number obsession and similar communication problems |