OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
95412281 almost 5 years ago

Zerkniesz na note/2506661 ?

39994759 almost 5 years ago

What is the copyright status of the source data?

I found https://www.inseed.td/ with "All Rights Reserved" in footer what seems to indicate that this data was not suitable for use in OpenStreetMap.

changeset/39994759

55962789 almost 5 years ago

"l don't have a law degree to judge about licensing issues." - that is why posting to imports mailing list BEFORE making edits is required and mandatory

55962789 almost 5 years ago

1) if licensing issues were not solved then import must not be done

2) has anyone asked local community whatever this import is desirable? If yes - please link where it was done

3) has anyone did required posting on imports mailing list? If yes, please link it

"It would be diffucult for me to write documentation cos my english skills is quite limited" - it can be in local language, local community can be and should be asked in a local language. And review of copyright situation also seems to require Finnish

"could you please do a favor for a community and fix the issue?" - I am unable to do this, as I am unable to speak Finnish so I would be unable to either ask local community or review copyright situation.

Also, doing this is responsibility of whoever makes import anyway.

23878745 almost 5 years ago

Is ref=yes tag is still used for any purpose?

39994759 almost 5 years ago

Please reply, I see that you are making an edits.

I also send a PM.

88016544 almost 5 years ago

Thanks for a reply!

"I am flowing GNS import guides as "

I asked on osm.wiki/Talk:GEOnet_Names_Server#What_is_the_point_of_dsg_string.3F and I plan to change this recommendation unless someone has a good reason for that.

"No, I do not know about this page before import"

Can you read and follow instructions there? Especially parts of documenting import and describing what actually happened and asking editing community whatever it is desirable to perform it?

55962789 almost 5 years ago

Also, see osm.wiki/Talk:Fi:Maastotietokanta ( needed due to https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/03/17/use-of-cc-by-data/ )

55962789 almost 5 years ago

> Are you guys so lazy that you can't be bothered to use the search?

Are you familiar with osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines ?

Especially with parts that require you to document this info so others are not obligated to use search?

55962789 almost 5 years ago

"require third parties to provide the same information when granting rights to copies of dataset(s) or products and services containing such data and"

in https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/en/opendata-licence-version1 in osm.wiki/Fi:Maastotietokanta/Road_Import_Stage1_Workflow

Is it something that was reviewed to be compatible with ODBL? Can you link post on imports mailing list confirming this?

55962789 almost 5 years ago

Also, what is the copyright status of imported data?

55962789 almost 5 years ago

I am planning to revert this import as undiscussed and not documented and introducing tags with unclear meaning.

If it was discussed and local community wants it to stay, please link relevant discussion and post to imports mailing list required by osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

50787584 almost 5 years ago

What is the meaning of man_made=tar_kiln tag?

97503008 almost 5 years ago

"Czy znajduje się tutaj droga rowerowa? Jakiego Typu?" i droga rowerowa jest oznaczona już na mapie jako osobna to mam zostawić notatkę "cycleway=separate"

Tak. Jak masz ochotę to możesz dodać tag cycleway=separate używając aplikacji Vespucci.

Możesz też wyłączyć to konkretne zadanie, nie jest specjalnie przydatne w Warszawie.

97771266 almost 5 years ago

@RicoElectrico - masz rację, nie ma podstaw podejrzewać że jest to jedna osoba

97771266 almost 5 years ago

A, czyli to był skrypt.

Ciekawe czy @Kaczor nowe konto założył.

97771266 almost 5 years ago

W sensie sprawnie, w ciągu 5 minut wrzucił 2055 budynków. Jak się to zablokuje to będzie mniej roboty z wycofaniem zmian.

97771266 almost 5 years ago

@RicoElectrico Masz pomysł jak znaleźć osoby które mogły by to konto zablokować?

97771266 almost 5 years ago

https://github.com/openstreetmap-polska/gugik2osm/issues/57

97770139 almost 5 years ago

1643 budynków w ciągu dwóch minut, czy w jakikolwiek sposób sprawdzasz co dodajesz?