OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
123455005 over 3 years ago

Nothing needs to be changed.
The three Emirates islands shall not be touched as I stated previously.
And about the Farsi Island, I already added it to Iran 3 months ago.
Regards.

123455005 over 3 years ago

Change what? And what will you “fix”?

123455005 over 3 years ago

Hello iriman,
No, it's part of the UAE still. They were invaded, occupied, and annexed in 1971 by an illegal Iranian military force. Maybe you need to read more about the history of the Arabian Gulf to understand its present.
Here is an official government website that states these islands are part of the UAE:
https://saiuae.gov.ae/ar/SAIConference/AboutUAE/Pages/About-UAE.aspx#:~:text=وجزيرة%20أبو%20موسى%20وطنب%20الصغرى%20وطنب%20الكبرى

And here are other websites showing the local Arabs on these Island with the UAE flag as they express their love for their homeland, the UAE, and their loyalty to the UAE President:
https://www.albayan.ae/across-the-uae/news-and-reports/2017-11-03-1.3088371
And:
http://wam.ae/ar/details/1395288812238

The current version follows the OSM guidelines. If you disagree with understanding the disputed OSM wiki, please tell me, how this differs from Crimea?
relation/3788824
It is mapped precisely like it, for example,
way/1054903304 is admin_level=2 which is the same as:
way/238797482

You said "change the borders to the initial state before your very first changes in changeset/120185536", in changeset/120185536 I added the Farisi island boundaries in relation to Iran (you welcome), do you want me to remove it from Iran?

Regards.

123455005 over 3 years ago

Why did you remove claimed_by:country2=United Arab Emirates and claimed_by:country2:code=AE ?
Please don't fiddle with the admin levels too in the Arabian Gulf region, these boarders are disputed.
I have reverted your edit in changeset/123477465.
Regards.

123477465 over 3 years ago

This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 123455005, 123454971.

122971575 over 3 years ago

Hello Iriman, as mentioned in the changeset comment, regards.

123230728 over 3 years ago

Renas, No. You, in this changeset, removed one tag and changed one.
You removed 'name:ku-Arab=بەخدا' which according to your last statement proves this tag was correct.
And you changed 'name:ckb' from "بەغدا" to "بەغا".
The official name of Baghdad in the Kurdistan regional government which is based in Erbil (Central) is "بەغدا"
https://gov.krd//the-governments-mission/erbil-baghdad-relations/
and it is the primary name in ckb Wikipedia is the same, "بەغدا" not "بەغا" https://ckb.wikipedia.org/wiki/بەغدا . There is not a single mention of the word you added "بەغا" in wikikpedia=ckb or any central Kurdish websites or even social media!
The sources I asked are from Erbil and Sulaymaniyah who speaks central Kurdish and they never heard of the one you changed the name to.
I gave you many chances to explain and prove your edits, but unfortunately, you didn't, and with the history of you removing the Arabic name tags from Northern Iraq, I believe your edit is with maliciously vandal intent as the word you used also means "prostitution".
This changeset has been reverted in changeset/123366170
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/123230728

123258645 over 3 years ago

The wiki tags you added is not affiliated with the subjects you edited.

123258357 over 3 years ago

name:ar means name In Arabic, you can't add another language in this tag.

123339780 over 3 years ago

Keep in mind that this relation/11068394 is different from relation/3826029, in which relation/11068394 is a district inside relation/3826029 which is a state, the district shares the same borders with the state.

123339548 over 3 years ago

I also removed "license_plate_code" as "KR" is not a license plate code, only a mark on the bottom left corner indicate the region. The codes for the region are 22 for Erbil, 21 for Sulaymaniyah, 24 for Duhok, and 23 for Halabja.
Source= https://moi.gov.krd/VP/

123230728 over 3 years ago

Hi Renas,
You are the one who changed the name and the one who should provide sources for your change. Simple as that.
All the Iraqi government websites say "بەغدا", even the Kurdish regional government websites. so I don't know where you came up with this word.
Even with my basic knowledge of the Kurdish language, today I asked my coworkers who are Kurds, Yazidis, and other Kurdish speakers from multiple ethnic groups, they all never heard of the word "بەغا" you added, and, I asked them what is Baghdad in Kurdish, all said "بەغدا".
I asked them again about the word "بەغا", and they said it might be "بغى" which has the same exact sound as "بەغا" the one you added, and "بغى" means prostitution which is super inappropriate for you to add on another city!
So, Sources. Provide some.
Regards.

123230728 over 3 years ago

Hello again Renas Azad,
in this changeset you changed the name:ckb from "بەغدا" to "بەغا". Why did you do this? The correct name in Kurdish 'name:ckb' is "بەغدا" or "بەغداد". Can you explain your edit with sources?
Regards.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/123230728

123230728 over 3 years ago

Hello again Renas Azad,
in this changeset you changed the name:ckb from "بەغدا" to "بەغا". Why did you do this? The correct name in Kurdish 'name:ckb' is "بەغدا" or "بەغداد". Can you explain your edit with sources?
Regards.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/123230728

123258841 over 3 years ago

Hello ESKH, your changeset comment say “adding places” but you are changing ‘name’ tag, why is that?
Why do you change the name tag?

121515664 over 3 years ago

The thing is, There were only 3 languages for the Airport, I added all the ones in the wiki, including the Turkish one. Those the ones I added were not on OSM before, so there was no conflict in naming. except for the Arabic one and the Persian, I corrected the Arabic base on my Arabic knowledge and left the Persian not added, I searched online for the Persian name, it was not avaliable in the Iraqi aviation's website and not avaliable on the Airport website. I was between 2 option, keep the Persian name that was added by a non Persian speaker, or add the one from wiki which is also might be incorrect too, so the best option was to leave it to Persian speakers, and it didn't take much, only 3 weeks for you to add it. Thanks and Regards.

121515664 over 3 years ago

Hi iriman, the name:fa doesn't match with the name on wikidata, feel free to add the correct one base on your knowable in Persian. Thanks.

123208353 over 3 years ago

This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 123208070.

123204649 over 3 years ago

Hello eng-abdulla albahrani, Thank you for your edits and being the only one from this town who's actually an active mapper. But can you please make the changeset comment that describes your edits in the changeset not just put your name in the changeset comment? Thanks.

123205732 over 3 years ago

Hello Bravo Mapper, what is the difference between this and node/2488304891? Regards.