OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
137915078 over 2 years ago

Hi ڕاستی, I saw you changed the admin_level for way/1106716750 and 2398083170 from 9 to 8, this is wrong, neighbourhoods (Mahala) should be on admin_level 9. Please revert. Regards.

136857159 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, can you explain in detail how it's "not completed" ?
And if you saw somethings on the map that are "not completed" you can complete them, it's an open map everyone can contribute. If someone let's say added a road on a country, you expect them to add all roads to country? of course not, we all edit the map.
Regards.

137899399 over 2 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, Please use good changeset comments that explain what you edited and why, with the source to back up the edit, I see you edited over 800 objects here with tens of tags changed, your changeset comment doesn't explain the changes you made, for example:
For nodes 9453485217, 8566924017, 10659935405, etc.. may I know why you removed the Arabic name entirely?
For nodes 5362350439, 5410873350, 5832950396, 7263485543 etc.. may I know why did you delete 'addr:country' tag?
And for way/771614591, 789786468, nodes 10117135317, 10117135317, 10812658505, etc.. why did you delete "addr:postcode"? it's a valid postal code in Erbil.
And you added tens of false postal codes, like way/789911116, 789911118, 789916157, 789916443, etc... the "postal code" you added is just the neighborhood (mahala) number and street/alley (zoqaq) number and the house (dar) number, these are not postal codes, and each one has its own tag and they shall not be put in "postal code"
May you please explain this edit of yours or at least the points I mentioned above?
Regards.

137811332 over 2 years ago

Hi ڕاستی, in this changeset you deleted 12 English names entirely from the ways. Please next time just move the English name from name to name:en instead of deleting them entirely.
Regards.

137808065 over 2 years ago

Hi,
You said "First show some respect." Can you please describe or explain how was I unrespectful?
And you said "about main name tag that you are not allowed add Arabic names." who said it's not allowed? where? Arabic is an official language of the country and an official language of the Kurdistan region as I sent you above the official link that say so. Also, you want me to add 'name' tags in Kurdish, how can I add it if I don't speak it and can not write it? for example, way/443813415/history you can see here I added the correct names and did not add the kurdish as it was not available in history, and even if I search wikipedia for the person who the street was named after him https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D8%B9%D9%88%D9%86%D9%8A_%D9%8A%D9%88%D8%B3%D9%81 , the wiki is only in Arabic and there is no Kurdish wiki so I can take the name of him to add in name:ckb.
And about the "#REVIEWED_BAD" thing, you just keep spamming them without understanding which is absolutely wrong and you shall not misuse the feature as if you do so, it might cover actual bad changeset in the osmcha history of the person, so it will be harder for people to see the actual bad edits.
About the "If you do that again I will report what you doing." Please don't wase the DWG time with this, try to communicate first, try to understand, maybe discuss this with the local community (@osm_iraq on telegram), and if nothing help maybe contact them if you thing you're in the right.
Regards.

137809656 over 2 years ago

"So why you do not corrected Kurdish names." because I don't speak Kurdish, I can read it as it share the same alphabet with Arabic, a language I'm familiar with, but can't speak Kurdish or type with it, therefore the wrong name shall be removed, unless you want me to change it to something grammarly or entirely wrong.
Regards.

137807761 over 2 years ago

A user commented about a change I made in this changeset regarding removing name tags, you can see the discussion in changeset/137809656. Regards.

137751801 over 2 years ago

Hi, We can add "Arabic" in main tag too, as it's an official language of the Kurdistan region [1], and the language that 95% Iraqis speak, and having only name:xx in a way without name is just weird.
[1] https://archive.gov.krd/dfr/dfr.gov.krd/p/p9728.html#:~:text=Language-,The%20Kurdistan%20Region%E2%80%99s%20official%20languages%20for%20government%20purposes%20are%20Kurdish%20and%20Arabic.,-The%20two%20most
Regards.

137809656 over 2 years ago

You mean in WAY: 443813415?
Yes name:ckb and name:ku have "Shqlawa street" in their name that's why I deleted them because the official name of the way is "Auni Yousif Street" which is written in a blue sign in the street that I surveyed.
Also, please next time, comment on the affected changeset, not other changeset, and I see that you "reviewed_bad" it which is absolutely wrong: https://osmcha.org/changesets/137807761/
Regards.

137808065 over 2 years ago

Hello, Arabic is an official language of Kurdistan region [1], And the language that 95% of Iraqi speaks, I added it not just for that but it's the language I'm familiar with, if you want me to add names in other languages that I don't speak that would be impossible unless you want some gibberish text.

[1] https://archive.gov.krd/dfr/dfr.gov.krd/p/p9728.html#:~:text=Language-,The%20Kurdistan%20Region%E2%80%99s%20official%20languages%20for%20government%20purposes%20are%20Kurdish%20and%20Arabic.,-The%20two%20most


Regards

137508568 over 2 years ago

Can you please specify what you are not satisfied with? you said "you did some incorrect edits" please mention them, give examples so I can help you if you need help, or if there was actually something wrong on the map.
You said "If there were any bad edits just revert it do not delete things and leave it." The first thing you must understand is that the editors here in OSM edit what they see on map, and most of them do not review the history of each way in order to know if there was a language tag deleted several months ago or not. Especially if this is the case, someone added the name of his shop on the roads, I deleted the vandal name and added the official name that I know, and in the language I'm familiar with, and in this case it was an official language by law in the Republic of Iraq and in the Kurdistan region, as I explained to you previously and commented the link above.
And about the "#REVIEWED_BAD" thing you did, it's false as you did previously in other changesets of mine, like changeset/127389768 and changest 127330628 etc...
Please don't be annoying, hostile or stubborn, try to communicate and be kind.
Best Regards.

137809656 over 2 years ago

Hello, Can you specify what way/node/relation are you talking about? as I did not change or remove any name in this changeset.
Regards.

137705580 over 2 years ago

Hello Lamassu, Thank you for your comment, glad to contribute.
Best Regards.

137632287 over 2 years ago

It was just a suggestion, if you see “education” is better, then education it is.
Best regards.

137632287 over 2 years ago

Thank you. What do you think about changing the landuse tag from education to college?
Best Regards.

137632287 over 2 years ago

Hi Renas, this node "معهد التدريب النفطي" you deleted because it's "duplicate" may I know where is the other node that this node is duplicate from?
Thanks.

136855148 over 2 years ago

Hello, I did not add this tag “short_name:ar”, its you the one who added it: way/530659957/history
Regards.

136855148 over 2 years ago

Hello, I assume you’re talking about the ways that had no names previously and I added the names in Arabic.
What is the problem? Ain’t Arabic an official language of the region alongside Kurdish?
But the reason I picked Arabic, because it’s a language I’m familiar with, and since it’s an official language to the country and the region then it’s correct.
See: https://archive.gov.krd/dfr/dfr.gov.krd/p/p9728.html#:~:text=Language-,The%20Kurdistan%20Region’s%20official%20languages%20for%20government%20purposes%20are%20Kurdish%20and%20Arabic.,-The%20two%20most
Regards.

137508568 over 2 years ago

Hi, again, I did not delete correct names, I only deleted wrong names which is self advertising, then I added the corrected names according to my knowledge and with the language I’m familiar with, which is an official language of the country and the Kurdistan region. If there were any names in another languages that were deleted/replaced previously by someone, then maybe you should contact them and comment on their changeset as they were the one who did the changeset.
Regards.

137508568 over 2 years ago

Hello, I did not delete office names or any correct information, I removed self advertising in name tag and put the official and correct name as a name of ways in an official language indeed.
Best regards.