OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
127389768 about 3 years ago

@ڕاستی, sure, you can make yourself that you don't know what I said and keep ignoring while you got busted and block multiple times for your vandalisms.
You want to discuss your issues with name:ar and the existing of name:ar you can discuss it with the community @osm_iraq in Telegram.
I will still monitor your edits for vandalism in this account and the others of yours.
You need to reply to my comments and question on your edits here: https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-discussion-comments?uid=4800812

127389768 about 3 years ago

@ڕاستی , you know these numbers/names that I deleted are fake and wrong, you yourself start to add the real numbers later after me in changeset/127440872 127441020 127440906 127441177 and 127472927.
If you disagree please provide a source back your claim.
I'm local and I know these are not the ones used.
I'm gonna explain this to the others since you alredy know these fake names were first added by a user named Dhiae in changeset/38086667 and 38086929 which is clearly an import from his map app that have fake and made up road names that he made so his app is easier to navigate, see this video they explain the names/numbering they made in their app: https://youtu.be/-wJhR3KFPR8
ڕاستی, I know why you asked this question, it's because I exposed your hundreds of vandal edits when you removed thousands of name:ar and Kurdification alot of areas near the Kurdish region. You asked this question here and did the same at changeset/127330628 and you rated them as "bad" in osmcha just to try to give me a "bad image" I guess?
Please stop being salty and do better.

127330628 about 3 years ago

Here is the text in the picture if someone want to translate:

مرحباً،

بخصوص طرق اربيل، لاحظت انك قمت باضافة الكثير الكثير من اسماء الطرق الغير مكتملة. بحيث تقوم بكتابة رقم المحلة فقط بدون رقم الزقاق. اتوقع انك قمت بذلك لعدم توفر رقم الزقاق لديك، ومن الممكن اضافته لاحقاً حسب رأيك اتوقع.

ولكن هذا يعتبر خطأ كبير جداً. ولاسباب كثيرة جداً، وسوف اذكر بعضها:

1- بعض المواقع تقوم بجلب اسم الطريق الذي يضاف لاول مرة ولاتقم بتحديثه بعدها في المستقبل. وهذا الشيء للاسف واجهناه في بغداد مثلا مع خرائط ابل،
مثلا هذه الشوارع في خرائط ابل التي تعتمد على بيانات الشارع المفتوح تظهر الزقاق فقط:
https://i.ibb.co/CWCZTbc/image.png
رغم تحديثها للمحلة والزقاق في خرائط الشارع المفتوح:
way/4387378
وتطبيقات اخرى ايضا تعتمد على بيانات الشارع المفتوح.

2-وجود رقم المحلة فقط في الاسم الخاص للشارع يجعل من الصعب للمحررين معرفة الشوارع التي لاتحتوي على رقم الزقاق لاضافته وجعله كاملاً.

3- وجود رقم المحلة فقط سوف يجعل الطريق الغير مكتمل لايظهر في الادوات التي تعطيك وتظهر لك الشوارع الغير مكتملة باسم. وبذلك لانستطيع معرفة الشوارع التي ليس بها رقم زقاق باستخدام الادوات.
مثل:
http://qa.poole.ch/
وغيرة مثل ريسولت ماب انمابد و اوفرباس توربو و كيب رايت و اواس موس وووو

4-وجود رقم المحلة فقط في الاسم الخاص للطريق يعتبر خاطئ حسب قوانين الشارع المفتوح. الخاصة بالاسم، حيث ان هذا الاسم الغير مكتمل سوف يكون مكرر بالمنطقة كلها ويعتبر سبام او ك اسم وصفي وليس اسم واقعي للطريق.

سؤال وجواب:

مالحل؟
الحل هو ازالة الاسماء الغير مكتملة نهائياً من الاسم العام.

اذا كيف يمكننا ابقاء رقم المحلة في حال الشخص كان يعرف رقم الزقاق فقط؟
من الممكن ان نقوم باضافته ك note=district xxx
حيث ان تاك النوت هو مخصص كملاحظة للمحررين

لماذا لا نقوم باستخدام تاك addr:district بدل تاك النوت؟
لان هذا التاك غير مخصص للطرق. ويمكن استخدامه في النقاط والمساحات فقط. يمكنكم مشاهدة Used on these elements
addr:district=*

مارأيك؟

تحياتي

127330628 about 3 years ago

Hi, read the changeset comment. Those are not street numbers, these are district numbers only without the alley number.
I’ve sent a message 2 weeks ago, read this: https://i.ibb.co/Vpvf06Y/2-FA630-CD-6-FA4-43-F3-9-A20-151-B8961590-D.png

118643562 about 3 years ago

Please use good changeset comment, thanks.

117577745 about 3 years ago

Why did you delete name:ar for node/5585896622 node/5587614931 ? they were correct!
And you also changed the 'name' tag from Arabic to Kurdish and remove the Arabic name entirely, why? thats for node/5476253822 node/5476264721 node/5585896622 and node/5587614931
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/117577745

127239021 about 3 years ago

Use good changeset comment
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/127239021

127310003 about 3 years ago

Use good changeset comment.

126936650 about 3 years ago

Hello Kurdistan-Map, a week ago I've sent you a long message about the situation of the alley names (Zoqaq) that you were added in Erbil, please read the message so we can fix the problem.
Thanks.

126905512 about 3 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, again, please, do not delete the Arabic names entirely!
in this changeseset you changed the 'name' from Arabic to Kurdish, In Erbil it is okay to change names to Kurdish since most of speakers speak Kurdish more than Arabic but you should've also moved these Arabic names to name:ar instead of removing them entirely...
Here you did it to: node/4389968390 node/4414048690 node/5527745621 node/5851858290 node/7856487085 node/9820263119 node/9929029118

126906554 about 3 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, again, please, do not delete the Arabic names entirely!
in this changeseset you changed the 'name' from Arabic to Kurdish, In Erbil it is okay to change names to Kurdish since most of speakers speak Kurdish more than Arabic but you should've also moved these Arabic names to name:ar instead of removing them entirely...
Here you did it to: node/10058493017

126953985 about 3 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, again, please, do not delete the Arabic names entirely!
in this changeseset you changed the 'name' from Arabic to Kurdish, In Erbil it is okay to change names to Kurdish since most of speakers speak Kurdish more than Arabic but you should've also moved these Arabic names to name:ar instead of removing them entirely...

126996235 about 3 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, again, please stop changing Arabic names in name:ar from Arabic to not Arabic.
for "way/334134728" you changed the name from:
مطعم اليوم
to
مطعم تودى
The word and the alphabet you used for the 2nd word is Kurdish not Arabic.
Please don't change name:ar from Arabic to another languages.

127006903 about 3 years ago

Hello ڕاستی, again, please, do not delete the Arabic names entirely!
in this changeseset you changed the 'name' from Arabic to Kurdish, In Erbil it is okay to change names to Kurdish since most of speakers speak Kurdish more than Arabic but you should've also moved these Arabic names to name:ar instead of removing them entirely...
Here you did it to: node/7772647685 node/7049901385 node/6628535585 node/5695825424 node/5607190004

127021943 about 3 years ago

Why did you change the 'name' from Arabic to Kurdish for: way/46778021, way/46779263, way/46946019, way/813319325, way/940398717?

126853149 over 3 years ago

Hi s@jj@d, the roads you edited were correct the way it was before, the sat images are not updated yet.
Please if you see the roads are aligned and straight and the one in the sat image is not paved that means the sat image is old and the residential area is paved now and has straight roads.
Please do not assume what a road should look like, please consider contacting local mappers you see who edit in the subject areas for local knowledge.
Also please use a good changeset comment next time. You should've explained to the mappers what you edit and why, so mappers can understand and know what your edit is. Having only "edit" is unclear and doesn't help.
Please read: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
I will revert your edits back to the correct way of roads.
Regards.

126754561 over 3 years ago

Yes because we can not have a descriptive name, Also it was wrong. So I added the official name.. Regards.

126223606 over 3 years ago

Please provide a source as I never heard of this change.
Also restore name:ar that you deleted for this road in changeset/63292043

126243462 over 3 years ago

The origins of the name didn’t mean it should be in that language.
The ‘name’ tag should always be in local spoken language. And what is the spoken language of the majority? Yes, Arabic, this is the one to use.

126566317 over 3 years ago

No, they were correct, I do understand all languages including Arabic, and Arabic were 100% correct. You removed them because you did not like them.
I suggest to keep your problems, political and ethnic views to yourself and not on the map.