OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
136608055 over 2 years ago

Feel free to do so.
Also forgot to add the source, the official source that I used for the naming is the website of Baghdad Bank. You can see the address of main branch in Baghdad, street 17.

136461284 over 2 years ago

@Abdullah Abdulrhman مرحبا صديقي العزيز! سيكون من دواعي سروري! أطيب التحيات.

136379177 over 2 years ago

I'm really giving you a chance and patience here. All I asked is a source.
I will give you a week to reply with a source.
Lastly, there is no "agreement" or "treaty" etc.. between us, as far as I remember you were naming left and right everything in Kurdish, and when I told you to please don't, you said you will stop in exchange for having 5 neighborhood names in Kirkuk city in bilingual names, and I said ok just for you to stop your edit war until someone from this 5 neighborhoods complain for having their neighborhood in bilingual not in the spoken language of the majority. You started to add bilingual names to other neighborhoods, towns, villages, and other places in Kirkuk even lakes and rivers where no one actually lives other than fish just like what I said previously.
Again, I will give you a week to reply with a source.
Best regards.

136379177 over 2 years ago

@Renas Azad again, please provide sources. I don't want your opinion, I want sources,
Again, here you changed 2 things that I asked you for their sources, node/2488268902 and relation/9636002, you made the node's name only in Kurdish while you say names should be bilingual, you are contradicting yourself here. And the relation, which is a lake that should be in language that the Kirkuk governorate speaks, which is +80% is Arabic.
I'm not gonna continue in this discussion if you keep refusing to give a source for your changes.
Regards.

136379177 over 2 years ago

Dear Renas, please stay on the subject.
You're drifting away saying things should be bilingual etc.. but this goes against what you did in this changeset when you changed node/2488268902 from having Arabic name to Kurdish. If you want bilingual then why did you changed it to be only in Kurdish? If there is nothing wrong with your edit then please provide a reason and source for this node.
And about the lake, it's a lake, not a city or village, no one live in the lake other than the fishes, the fishes doesn't speak a language, therefore the name of the lake should be in the spoken language in state.
Best Regards.

136379177 over 2 years ago

Hi, You are the one you made the changeset, therefore, please provide a source for your edit.
Regards.

134671639 over 2 years ago

Hello, what is the source of "Erbil Train Station" and all the railways you added in Erbil? it doesn't show on any sat image..
Regards.

136379177 over 2 years ago

Hello Renas Azad, Here in OSM we map things on the ground and in the present day time, not historically. So please provide actual sources for your changes.
Thank you.

135447901 over 2 years ago

^ Mention was suppose to be for @ittle_maper telling him @K1u9r8d9 is probably fiction mapping

135447901 over 2 years ago

@K1u9r8d9 I think he's fiction mapping. he also added rails that is not on the ground..

136379177 over 2 years ago

+ You can learn more here:
name=*
Best Regards.

136379177 over 2 years ago

Hi,
1-For node/2488268902 you changed the name from Arabic to Kurdish only not in bilingual and that's not what you said here. May I know why? and what is your source to have it only in Kurdish?
2-For relation/9636002, the lake that you changed the name to be bilingual, this is wrong, because the 'name' should be for the spoken language of the area, That would be Arabic, Kurdish is a spoken language for most of the kurds in Kirkuk which is less than 20% of Kirkuk province population. Example, Canada, it's an official bilingual country by law, and you see Cities are entirely in English with no French for example. the value that should be used in 'name' should be the spoken language of the area.
Best regards.

136379177 over 2 years ago

Hi Renas, why did you change the name for relation/9636002 and node/2488268902? Can you please provide a source for this change and why? Thank you.

135717306 over 2 years ago

Hi Renas Azad,
Why did you add a 2nd name to the name tag and made it a bilingual?
Can you please provide a the reason and source?
Regards.

135847140 over 2 years ago

Hello again Renas Azad,
Please use good changeset so the mappers know what you edited.
For example in this changeset you could've said "changing village name from xxx to yyy" and the source is "xyxy". "Edit Village name." is not a good changeset.
osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Regards.

135961790 over 2 years ago

Hello again Renas Azad,
Please use good changeset so the mappers know what you edited.
For example in this changeset you could've said "changing village name from xxx to yyy" and the source is "xyxy". "Edit Village name." is not a good changeset.
osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
Regards.

136023737 over 2 years ago

I reverted this changeset for many reasons,
1-The Kurds who live in this town is less than 12%. And almost all of them speak Arabic only.
2-You used an old Kurdish name not even the current one in the Kurdish name.
Best Regards.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sadiyah#:~:text=1997.%5B16%5D-,More%20recent%20estimates%20state%20that%20Kurds%20constituted%2038%25%20in%202003%20and%2012%25%20in%202012,-.%5B17%5D

136023737 over 2 years ago

This changeset has been reverted in changeset/136035783 when changeset comment is "revert changeset/136023737, removed an old name in a non local language in main 'name' tag"

136023737 over 2 years ago

What is your source that the people here speak Kurdish?
Ethnic background doesn't always mean they speak a specific a language in that area.
Regards.

136023593 over 2 years ago

What is your source that the people here speak Kurdish?
Ethnic background doesn't always mean they speak a specific a language in that area.
Regards.