Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 127706969 | about 3 years ago | 4. Someone even suggested it should be "Luk Ngau Peak". This shows there is no commonly used variation. |
| 127706969 | about 3 years ago | 1. You are not allowed to decide directly from Wikipedia. This is copyright infringement
|
| 127638673 | about 3 years ago | 4. `addr:region=Hong Kong` is not correct either. |
| 127638673 | about 3 years ago | 3. eg is south of Tin Shui Wai station TIn Sui Wai? Can be no, because they are covered in Hung Shui Kiu and Ping Shan OZP respectively. But postal address and common use might be yes. Same for Fung Ka Wai east of Tin Tsz Road. |
| 127638748 | about 3 years ago | This is obviously wrong when TKO is more than that. |
| 127638673 | about 3 years ago | 1. `place=town` is an abstract concept that shouldn't have a defined area
|
| 125934804 | about 3 years ago | Moved to `name:yue-Latn=` |
| 125931068 | about 3 years ago | Moved to `name:yue-Latn=` |
| 127503390 | over 3 years ago | 5. Please don't make up English name by transliteration or romanization. `name:*=` is for those in common use by the public. Use `old_name:yue-Latn`. |
| 127506830 | over 3 years ago | There's no `natural=pass`. In OSM. `=saddle` and `mountain_pass=yes` are distinguished clearly. The former is a low point compared to the surroundings on a mountain. The latter is the highest point of a road going through a mountain. There can be a mountain pass without saddle, and vice versa. They often do not coincident. |
| 127503390 | over 3 years ago | 3. Please use more descriptive changeset comments, not repeating the same vague sentence
|
| 127503390 | over 3 years ago | 1. Please don't cite random "online" source. `name=` is the common name in use by the public currently, not what you or someone or history think it should be.
|
| 127482201 | over 3 years ago | It's not needed to have address-only names, unless it has special styling. (eg 700 Nathan; Nathan 700, Seven Hundred Nathan, etc) |
| 127386022 | over 3 years ago | Ok, I think you two are thinking about different parts. Let me see.... |
| 127406757 | over 3 years ago | Please don't add descriptive labels to `name=`. That's for actual proper names only. Use `description:zh=`. |
| 127386022 | over 3 years ago | What's wrong with this one? There's clearly something there. |
| 127365723 | over 3 years ago | 1. Please don't cite random "online" source. `name=` is the common name in use by the public currently, not what you or someone or history think it should be.
|
| 127361629 | over 3 years ago | Please don't add `ele=` to `=ridge`. This doesn't make sense. |
| 127334396 | over 3 years ago | 1. Another example is Chek Lap Kok being included in Tung Chung |
| 127334396 | over 3 years ago | (Btw if you are using your own instance, you could adjust how it works) |