OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
175349626 18 days ago

This is not a net improvement, as `name:en=` is wrongly changed, breaking any application using it for English names to find and show bus stops. Presumably no apps are able to relate the `=bus_station` with `=bus_stop` directly and visibly.
If you know this is bad, you should use "Notes". And at least `description=` can be used, which is surely supported.

175339959 19 days ago

I don't know what you are doing. But you should multi-select by holding [Shift] as usual.

175339959 19 days ago

Please don't blindly merge different road sections. They are split to show different attributes.

175195537 19 days ago

2. As I said, whether this has been an estate would be covered by `abandoned:landuse=residential`

175195537 19 days ago

2. Eg if Wang Chi House returns, but the Court voted to rebuild, it's still `=residential` until they move out

175195537 19 days ago

1. The structure is independent of the use. If there's no one living there , it's not `=residential` now. Unless you are arguing it's a short-term closure.
2. `landuse=` is describing use, and OSM is about the existing reality. Legal status and plans don't affect that.

175264666 19 days ago

That has the entire road blocked, and physically. You said there are sidewalks available here.

175228401 20 days ago

Please don't remove `is_in:suburb=` here. Only unstructured `is_in=` is deprecated, not `is_in:*=` structured. There's no `boundary=administrative` to replace it.

175264666 20 days ago

Some applications may not process `footway=sidewalk` in a simplified view. Snapping may snap to the roadway, causing them not to be used.

175300460 20 days ago

Please don't change `name:zh=` to `name:yue-Hant=` , as the label of "Mandarin Chinese" is simply wrong or misapplied by default. It means unspecified Sinitic langauges.

175264666 20 days ago

A congested or crowded road doesn't mean you are not allowed to walk on it. The presence of `footway=sidewalk` doesn't determine what its `highway=` road should be, which can be `=use_sidepath` if pedestrian are legally prohibited from the roadway.

175195537 20 days ago

1. What do you mean by there's "no actual changes to the estate itself"? `landuse=` is about the use. The use has changed from being uninhabited to inhabited.
2. That's untrue. Abandonment without demolition is still `=brownfield` , as with many such polluted industries in reality in the common language.
3. I don't see what's "painfully obvious". This can be described by `abandoned:landuse=residential` , and there are still `building=apartments` inside.

175264666 21 days ago

`access=` is interpreted for all modes. Can pedestrians walk there?

175195537 21 days ago

OSM is about the existing reality, and `landuse=` the existing use. `=brownfield` means it's not inhabited.

175232142 22 days ago

Please don't create duplicates. Edit the existing ones.

175220587 22 days ago

If you are doing this, you would need to correct the `start_date`

175195537 22 days ago

You could argue the `ruin*:landuse=residential` , but it's not being lived in now. It's a `=brownfield` , not `=residential`

175203713 22 days ago

`access=emergency` is not used, and `emegency=` doesn't show whether it's originally EVA-only. Emegency units using it should be treated as short-term closures functionally, not the same physical permanent damages.

175156192 23 days ago

1. Please use meaningful upload comment, not a single useless word
2. Please explain what you want to do. `disused=yes` has already been used here. It shouldn't be deleted.

175137330 24 days ago

Notice the `=city` is `admin_centre` , and `=state` the `label`