OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
165050327 8 months ago

1. Please use descriptive upload comments, and not reuse the same as before. You are mostly editing buildings here.
2. You broken the 3D modeling here. Please study how `building:part=` are used before you touch them. Most `building=` in HK are "wrong" as they are a legacy of older methods.

164619809 8 months ago

Removed `name=` , kept `old_name=`

164919426 8 months ago

You response makes no sense. This is not a
philosophical discussion. Why is Tan Shan Teng mentioned by it?
You didn't answer how to tell their exact position. If this is the most accurate you can get, it's not accurate enough.

164666053 8 months ago

Yeah, your claim immediately fails here node/12735511795/history/1

164963508 8 months ago

No, it's not the same. No one calls it that now.

164919426 8 months ago

Even it's true historically, reminder again `name=` is what's commonly used by the public now. Please add historical names to OHM.

164919426 8 months ago

Text alone can't prove anything. You can't tell what's where, especially with how much the terrain has been altered here. The date describe is unknown. Their source is also not given. Heights are missing as well.

164963508 8 months ago

This is already clearly indicating it's for a `demolished:place=hamlet`

164963508 8 months ago

Can you please stop adding random `place=` ?

164723207 8 months ago

Yes, there's something, but not lanes. The left half is shared-use, where bikes need to keep right (center), and pedestrians keep left. There's only a pair of small pictograms towards the sides as a reminder, which doesn't take up the entire "lane". No different surfacing. The right half is a part of the sidewalk.

164848961 8 months ago

It's not possible to add them properly on most if not all such end-user map apps. They are not designed for editing. An `entrance=` needs to be attached to the `building=` directly.

164723207 8 months ago

Tried to divide it into `footway:*=` and `cycleway:*=` , but it doesn't work quite nice. `cycleway*:bicycle:*=` is still needed.

164848961 8 months ago

This is how the default style here shows different `entrance=` , as a small square dot. Other applications would use other icons.

164723207 8 months ago

It's `segregated=no` . There's no `lanes=` for it, nor any visible physical characteristics that would divide it into `*:lanes=` on the left half.

164862842 8 months ago

Please reply to previous changesets from your different accounts. `bus=private` is needed in HK to distinguish franchised bus.

164848961 8 months ago

Already corrected. The `addr:street=` is wrong because you added `addr:housenumber=25` with it, making it 25 Tsuen Wan Market St.

164848961 8 months ago

Please don't upload duplicates to the public database. This functionality is not for private use. The address is wrong as well.

164848701 8 months ago

Please don't delete them directly, as they can contain addresses, and still represent a store space. This makes tracking and updating more difficult. Change it to a plain "point", or "vacant".

164775602 9 months ago

And there's no naming, numbering. or identification for them to qualify as a `=route`

164775602 9 months ago

It's enough to add `*cn=yes`