Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 162337668 | 10 months ago | Can you please check it yourself after interpreting and making assumptions. Fish Wave is signposted on both ends of the outer section. The fishing platform is only one part of the area. Theme Area 3 is clearly shown to be an entire section between the toilet and Harbour North. |
| 162337668 | 10 months ago | The `man_made=bridge` polygons were to be split across the `bridge=movable` . You should check the Fish Wave area extends westwards to the outside, and I believe the rings on the fencing are holder stands for fish rods. |
| 162456568 | 10 months ago | This is for the `man_made=bridge` structure. It's not one whole continous walkable area either. |
| 162442329 | 10 months ago | The problem is there's no "official" name for the north bridge, and the TD notice you might have checked used "Northern Bridge" to refer to it afterwards as well. `name=` is defined as commonly used by the public, or what's signposted.
|
| 162422006 | 10 months ago | Southern Bridge is actually named https://www.td.gov.hk/en/traffic_notices/index_id_74356.html
|
| 162422006 | 10 months ago | Please check that the Northern Bridge hasn't been named this. What you might have referred to is in lowercase "footbridge". This should not be interpreted as a proper name. |
| 162419502 | 10 months ago | Please don't casually change `place=` , as this is a controversial issue. This may be kept as `=locality` , as this refers to a very small reclaimed one to the west. It's dubious whether the Sky Pier Basin created by the artificial island should refer to that. |
| 162286822 | 11 months ago | 3. Please don't blindly merge different sections. They are split for different reasons.
|
| 162286822 | 11 months ago | 2. Please split your uploads in different areas, and be more descriptive in the comments |
| 162286822 | 11 months ago | Please read that percentages not ratios should be used in `incline=` |
| 162249128 | 11 months ago | Have you actually checked whether it's an EVA? Because I have. |
| 162248937 | 11 months ago | Please read that `=busway` is only used for phyiscally-separated high-standard busways in the likes of "BRT", not bus lanes which is here `oneway:bus:conditional=` + `bus:backward=` |
| 162202075 | 11 months ago | Please don't directly delete them, as they contain addresses, and still represent a store space. This makes tracking and updating more difficult, wasting previous efforts. Change it to a plain "point", or "vacant shop". |
| 162197211 | 11 months ago | `=permit` is defined as ordinary granted to everyone. `=private` should be used for "permit" meaning restricted. |
| 162100739 | 11 months ago | `addr:place=` is used in villages for `addr:housenumber=` numbering each address directly, and matching a `place=` (there's none here) . `addr:place=` also doesn't work when there are housing estates inside villages. The emergent practice in HK is to use `addr:housename=` for estate names, and `addr:unit=` for individual tower units (think Tower 1A for a building split into 2, which fits the wiki description for different stairs) or houses. |
| 162004648 | 11 months ago | 2. Please don't delete the `=service` roads |
| 162004648 | 11 months ago | Please don't delete the long-term permanent proposals. This is only temporary short-term. |
| 162045603 | 11 months ago | Please don't delete other things when you aren't fixing it. Even it has been degraded, it shouldn't be deleted directly either. |
| 161877207 | 11 months ago | The `highway=` and `place=` should be separated in this case. The `=fountain` is still part of the `=square` , only that it's no walkable. |
| 161841536 | 11 months ago | `=ferry_terminal` is already added on the `=pier` area. This is the `=berth` as `=stop_position` , reflecting the name used on the ferry routes. |