OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
160232700 about 1 year ago

There's no necessity to create `leisure=track` on a sidewalk. There's no physical separation between them. You didn't change the `route=foot` , and it's more for `=highway` . There's basically no `type=` for `=track` , and it's arguably a `route=foot` than `type=circuit`

160074441 about 1 year ago

It was moved away for some unknown reason only. I don't know why.

160074441 about 1 year ago

You misunderstood this one. It's being reconstructed. It has temporary offices.

160028004 about 1 year ago

2. Furthermore here, the gazetted "Aberdeen Tunnel" refers to the road as west as Wong Chuk Hang Rd. So you need to think carefully about what you are representing accurately and precisely.

160028004 about 1 year ago

Fundamentally, `type=street` , `type=associatedstreet` , etc aren't popular. A wiki could be updated to use `name=` queries, to not rely on manually creating and maintaining an object.

160028004 about 1 year ago

This was already discussed recently. `route=road` is already used for numbered routes. This is not one.
You need to distinguish between `type=street` for most closely gazetted street names, and `type=tunnel` for tunnel structures (which can include different features `railway=` and `man_made=pipeline` etc) . For wiki compatibility, it has been discussed to use `route=street` . For arbitrary sections of roads that aren't gazetted street names, I suggest `route=highway` first similar to `route=railway`

159877531 about 1 year ago

Please don't add `building=` for the purpose of rendering. It's only a limitation by a particular renderer.

159875798 about 1 year ago

Please don't delete after removing `highway=` as a mistake. `man_made=bridge` and them are different features.

159839791 about 1 year ago

2. Please keep openings to the same day. It's difficult to define.

159865433 about 1 year ago

Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=` which is for proper names only. `sport=` should be used.

159839791 about 1 year ago

Please don't add `shop=mall` to all `building=` . That's duplicating. They are already indicated as `=retail` , with a spatial relationship of being inside a `=mall` covering the all of them.

159684144 about 1 year ago

2. So this also duplicates with the other already created `=police`

159684144 about 1 year ago

`amenity=police` is used for public-facing police facilities. This is a complex of many units. It's mainly the division being the front office.

159561644 about 1 year ago

Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=` , which is for proper names only. There's already `description=` used. Even if you care about raster rendering, making it too long will exactly cause it to be not rendered at all.

159447013 about 1 year ago

Please don't remove `building=` from a `landuse=residential` that coincides. It's obvious from `building:levels=`

159415941 about 1 year ago

An offices building should simply be `=office`

159415699 about 1 year ago

3. Adding `building=` to the entire site is wrong

159415699 about 1 year ago

1. As mentioned before, please keep `office=` for actual offices. Not a site, or building.
2. `=townhall` has special meaning that may be useful for expressing a government center

159391392 about 1 year ago

Please don't add descriptor labels and titles as "Site at"` . `name=` is for proper names only. The "site" was only added after a recent argument.

159409668 about 1 year ago

There's already `covered=yes` . Only `=building_passage` should be considered.