OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
122254313 over 3 years ago

This is not an etymological discussion. `addr:place=` needs to be a village with its own house-number, in lieu of house-number associated with. Housing estates don't have this house-number assigned inside. Quite the opposite, in larger developments with their own streets (eg Meifoo, Whampoa, Taikoo Shing), they are assigned house-numbers on those streets.
Here is a list of housing estates with village house-number currently mapped. https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1jqH
There are many other with `addr:place=` but not yet tagged with `addr:housenumber=`. You can query for them, and compare other sources.

122254313 over 3 years ago

`addr:parentstreet=` + `addr:street=` is inaccurate, and doesn't solve the issue. An `addr:building=` would be more suitable for a building itself.

122254313 over 3 years ago

This is not the case. `addr:housename=` is same as `addr:housenumber=`, which in HK will be applied to the entire housing estate. Even if you find it misleading, `addr:place=` is for villages with `addr:housenumber=`. In fact, there are housing estates in villages using village house-number, meaning a conflict.

122467400 over 3 years ago

Secondarily, points on opposite directions are aligned to each other.

122467400 over 3 years ago

As I said before, please don't move lines upstream beyond the physical separation. `change:lanes=` is already used here.

122412990 over 3 years ago

Please don't remove the address.

122409300 over 3 years ago

Please don't change `=pedestrian` to `=footway` when it's a emergency or maintenance vehicular access.

122395648 over 3 years ago

Please don't add bracketed descriptor labels in `name=`. That's for proper names only. Use `description:zh=`.

122317045 over 3 years ago

HI, can your team stop removing `highway=footway` + `area=yes`, or at least change them to `area:highway=footway`? For example this one is a wide open sea in front of the mall with a brand statue, so it's natural someone wants to draw it. Can you share what's the validation issue.

122311931 over 3 years ago

Please don't extend turning lanes to sections without physical separation.

122305263 over 3 years ago

Please check the lanes. This is required on top of `change:lanes=`.

122302146 over 3 years ago

Please don't use Taiwan name of Sukiya. HK has no such branding.

122284243 over 3 years ago

Please don't delete the address.

122268752 over 3 years ago

`man_made=chimney` only refers to a vent stack. It is not a replacement for the entire `building=`.

122250650 over 3 years ago

Ok I don't know how integrated the soil, building, and deck is.

122254313 over 3 years ago

2. For the 2nd method, the `type=multipolygon` can then be changed to `type=building` with `part`, and the `outline` included.

122254313 over 3 years ago

1. `addr:place=` is only used for villages with house-numbers.
2. Multipolygon can't have touching sub-areas. You need to either split the shape at the common segments to use it; or not use it by drawing an outline over all 3 sections, and changing them to `building:part=`.

122250650 over 3 years ago

Please don't merge `area:highway=` + `bridge=yes` or `man_made=bridge`.

122212502 over 3 years ago

2. Please don't delete those temporarily closed or in reconstruction.

122212502 over 3 years ago

Please don't move what's already been tagged with `placement=transition` and `change:lanes=`.