OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
147535530 almost 2 years ago

I'm not talking about the structures in front of the Main Building in the first place. In fact from imagery alone, they can already be seen as the ones that are misaligned, not the roads. On the other hand, you caused a large gap between the carriageways and north side along Haking Wong and Centennial Campus. Even on imagery, the south side sidewalk can be seen as misaligned.

147608671 almost 2 years ago

Have I not reminded you there should not be such brackets? osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
If you make them long, it won't be displayed in some maps easily either. You can't expect the label to have all info.

147574188 almost 2 years ago

I already gave you the benefit of doubt of what seems to be a descriptor title to make it the `official_name=`

147574188 almost 2 years ago

This is actually wrong. The boards show "PAI TAU STREET TO SHING MUN COUNTRY PARK COUNTRY TRAIL". You don't even know the correct name. Then is it really a "common name"?

147535530 almost 2 years ago

Your alignment seems wrong. Don't merely follow one certain imagery in certain areas. It can be very inaccurate, especially in hilly terrain. The offset will not be constant in all directions in even a small extent.

147521811 almost 2 years ago

Please don't remove the addresses. They still exists.

145648237 almost 2 years ago

Please don't delete the rest of the area. Move it as you have done for the `=park`.

147494574 almost 2 years ago

The meaning on each of them is already partially expressed by `building=retail`

147494574 almost 2 years ago

Don't use `=mall` for each phase or building. There should only be one of it for each shopping center. It will include Phase 1 as well.

147466859 almost 2 years ago

Please don't add brackets and such descriptive labels. `name=` is for the proper name only. Use `description=` if truly needed.

145378264 almost 2 years ago

You deleted a section to make an invalid touching rings `=boundary` ...

147315064 almost 2 years ago

Please avoid connecting `proposed:highway=` unless you know the junction arrangement. Is it an at-grade intersection, roundabout, or grade-separated interchange? How does it reserve for connecting Northern Metropolis Highway?. This makes editing other opened features more difficult.

147208408 almost 2 years ago

Please don't delete `barrier=` when you can clearly move them sideways...

146993715 almost 2 years ago

The name has already been consulted. Your useless "update" comment doesn't do anything but make it worse.
Please don't directly copy the PWP title. `name=` is the proper name only. It should reflect what it will open as. Don't add comma addresses, brackets , etc. Descriptor labels belong to `description=` .

146581319 almost 2 years ago

1. Please be careful when panning. You accidentally moved a `building=` across the street.
2. `layer=10` doesn't make sense. There is already `building:levels=10` .
3. It's a `=apartments` , not `=university`

147038841 almost 2 years ago

Hi Fizz thx for this first. I didn't change it as the situation is complicated here. This service does everything for the government aside from rescue and medical, including law enforcement, firefighting, surveying, VIP transport, weather, and construction. So I simply used `=air` and not even `=air_rescue` . I didn't notice your proposal deprecated it.

146977832 almost 2 years ago

Please don't upload personal test data to a public database. This is vandalism.

146970366 almost 2 years ago

Please don't add the whole title. `name=` is for common and proper names only.

146857145 almost 2 years ago

Please note that `=permit` has a specific meaning "routinely granted" defined. It was debated before.https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/draft-feature-proposal-specific-permits-exceptional-permit/104071/
It's not suitable for use in "except with permit". That's at most `=private` in almost all cases.

146810913 almost 2 years ago

2. `operator=` is not suitable for roles in the construction works. That should be `developer=` , `architect=` , ,`builder=` , etc. At most, it's an `owner=` .