OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
149843868 over 1 year ago

The map is not "being made worse." It's not "turning into OHM" either. If "having no data is much better," why are life cycle prefixes in widespread use? The goal should not be to return the state of OSM back to 2006. Instead add a fixme tag, add a note, make a post. Deleting way history does not improve the map or help your fellow editors. Constantly checking for deletions in your local area is not something most editors want to devote an extensive amount of time to.

149843868 over 1 year ago

@Friendly_Ghost

I don't see how removing sites that are currently still vacant, and have not been redeveloped is "turning OSM into OHM." If they had been redeveloped, and the way was dating back decades I would be inclined to agree. However, St. Catherine's Indian School is still vacant and has changed ownership several times. It is distinct from the National Cemetery, and has not been redeveloped. It has been deleted and no longer appears on the map. Deleting them removes the way's history, and in some cases address information. (way/732493108/history#map=4/38.65/-83.84)

Likewise, The Gizmo Store only recently closed, and has not been changed into anything else. I would understand changing these ways to a "disused:" prefix, but outright removal of all names and amenity tags makes it less clear what the site is, or that it is still vacant.

Thanks for your reply,
- Kovirii

149843868 over 1 year ago

Hello again,
I see that you completely deleted certain ways, without local knowledge. This makes them difficult to restore, or requires other editors to recreate them.
Please do not do this.
https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-change-viz?c=149843868#3/46.32/-103.27
- Kovirii

149843868 over 1 year ago

Hello,
Please do not automatically remove tags such as "old_name" and "name." This removes useful information used by both mappers and the public. Additionally, how did you determine it was correct to delete "shop=vacant?"
As seen here: https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/437189759

Thanks,
- Kovirii

138242430 over 2 years ago

Please copy over existing address information when deleting existing points
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/138242430

134645473 over 2 years ago

No problem, just wanted to make you aware.

134645473 over 2 years ago

It appears this edit incorrectly replaced the "network" tag on the subway relation with "building:stairs" instead.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/134645473

136921609 over 2 years ago

Cool!

130136464 over 2 years ago

Forest Road 524

128629772 almost 3 years ago

transferred from where? the location is too far to the west, i've since moved it.

74558902 almost 3 years ago

Why do the roads wiggle?

122487798 almost 3 years ago

Corrected, thanks for pointing it out!

110687353 about 3 years ago

Still rehabbing Trail 243?

100968254 about 3 years ago

Well excuse me. Maybe they didn't load.

120354633 over 3 years ago

You are correct, thanks for pointing this out.

109054906 over 3 years ago

Hello, I'm now seeing your note on this (way/784710733) and I still see activity on Strava. A tiny bit near the intersection appears on one USGS quad, however most of it doesn't. It appears to follow the ridge between peaks. Unsure about the quality of the trail myself.

62189944 almost 5 years ago

What is the source for all the creeks in Dulce, NM?

87110482 almost 5 years ago

The Office depot moved to where the movie theater used to be, on the other side of the mall.

97721686 almost 5 years ago

While I would imagine access is restricted in general, you are correct, the plant is closed, and permanently so.

71265742 about 5 years ago

These are from an old import, so some research and/or guesswork is required to find the appropriate location for them.