OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
158344599 about 1 year ago

Hi,
It seems to me that you have choosen a wrong tag for way/1161180019 because this looks like a building and leisure=horse_riding is not a tag for a building. If this building is an indoor arena for horse riding you can use building=riding_hall (like here: way/1056869661).

158187082 about 1 year ago

Hi,
why did you retag way/1051758731 from leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian to leisure=horse_riding? I think this area was correctly tagged as a riding arena, compare osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian). Now, after you retagged it, therae is a small riding centre mapped inside of a large one (way/1051758730), what does not makle sense.

158217938 about 1 year ago

Hi,
die Flächen, die du kürzlich (und auch früher) mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt hast (z.B. way/1327270625 und way/1327270626), sehen (auf den Luftbildern) nicht aus wie Reitanlagen (im Sinne von osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding), die sehen aus wie Reitplätze oder wie Paddocks. In OSM werden Reitplätze üblicherweise mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian getaggt, so wie z.B. way/1026792395 (von dir früher auch schon verwendet). Paddocks kann man z.B. mit osm.wiki/DE:Tag:landuse=animal_keeping taggen.

In JOSM kann man Reitplätze mit dem Preset "Pferdesport" taggen (wird leider nicht gefunden wenn man nach "Reitplatz" sucht).

Hier noch zwei Beispiele aus deiner Gegend, wo die Tags richtig verwendet wurden:
way/1118422617#map=16/49.30961/11.93255&layers=P
way/178300008#map=18/48.485631/11.925407&layers=P
vgl. osm.wiki/DE:How_to_map_a/R#Reitstall

158144556 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/72256544 is some building and not an equestrian centre, and because you have removed building=yes this building is no longer rendered on the standard map.

If you want to map an equestrian centre see:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/653383310#map=17/49.045618/2.241447&layers=P (example)

158072187 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1325539908 is only a riding arena and not a complete riding centre. Therefore it should better be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, like here:
way/1220983616#map=18/10.426618/-66.801413&layers=P
See also: osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

158102127 about 1 year ago

Još jedan automatski prijevod:
Haj
way/1086751698 bi trebalo bolje označiti s leisure=horse_riding nego leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, što se odnosi samo na područje u kojem se konji jašu. Usporediti: osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(konjički) way/856426537

158102127 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1086751698 should better be tagged with leisure=horse_riding than with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, which only applies to the area in which the horses are ridden. Compare:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/856426537

Automatyczne tłumaczenie:
Cześć,
way/1086751698 powinien być lepiej oznaczony jako leisure=horse_riding niż leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, który dotyczy tylko obszaru, w którym konie są ujeżdżane. Porównaj:
osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)
way/856426537

157957893 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1324330898 does not look like a riding centre; it looks more like a riding arena, similar to way/1168323324. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian.

Also way/499972019 is not a riding centre, it is a building, but because you have removed the tag building=yes it is no longer rendered as a building on the map.

The tag leisure=horse_riding should be used for the whole area of a riding centre and not for specific buildings, arenas or other things in a riding centre, examples: way/1312659183 and node/11837680455; compare osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

157891313 about 1 year ago

Hi,
You have removed the building tag from way/612258883 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding. Therefore the building is no longer rendered as a building. The tag leisure=horse_riding is actually not intended for buildings, but for the entire area of the equestrian center. See
leisure=horse_riding.
The riding centre can better be mapped separately from the building (area or node), example: way/97438164

157893798 about 1 year ago

Hi,
Are you sure that way/1323938748 is a riding centre (leisure=horse_riding)? On PDOK aerial it looks like a riding arena, similar to way/1079532359 (tags: leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian); compare leisure=horse_riding

157858997 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1323771239 looks like a riding arena and not like a riding centre (leisure=horse_riding). In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, examples: way/607473493 and way/1116841118; compare leisure=horse_riding.

In JOSM you can use the preset for equestrian sport to tag them.

157771138 about 1 year ago

Hi,
You have removed the building tag from way/488753974 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding. Therefore the building is no longer renderes as a building. The horse_riding tag is actually not intended for buildings, but for the entire area of the equestrian center. See
osm.wiki/Tag%3Aleisure%3Dhorse_riding.
The riding centre can be mapped as a separate object (area or node), examples: way/703036885#map=18/53.092383/6.694458&layers=P, node/8586932566#map=18/52.718887/6.143715&layers=P

(There was a similar discussion one year ago: changeset/142592518)

157196848 about 1 year ago

I was afraid that you would make more changes like that. That is why I wanted to draw your attention to it. If you hadn't corrected it yourself, I would probably have done it myself at some point. But it is better the way it is now :)

157196848 about 1 year ago

I don't understand this answer.

As I wrote at the beginning, the area way/1298119563 looks like a riding arena, and in OSM riding arenas are normally tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. And that's how it was before you changed it.

It looks like you are mixing up the tags, because way/795246825 is an equestrian centre and should be tagged with leisure=horse_riding instead of leisure=pitch.

This is correct: way/287693369, compare osm.wiki/How_to_map_a#Riding_centre_(equestrian)

157435090 about 1 year ago

Thanks!

157246098 about 1 year ago

leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian ist nach WIki richtig für Reitplätze. Ich verstehe nicht, wo das Problem liegt. Du hast doch im Laufe der Jahre schon einen Haufen Reitplätze so getaggt. Vielleicht meinst du, dass leisure=horse_riding ein gleichbedeutendes Alternativ-Tag wäre (way/559738440/history deutet darauf hin). Aber das ist es nicht. Der Unterschied ist so wie bei Tennisplatz contra Tennisanlage. Eine Reit-/Tennis-Anlage kann einen oder mehrere Reit-/Tennis-Plätze oder -Hallen sowie sonstige Gebäude und Flächen enthalten. Siehe Wiki. Hier ein Beispiel aus deiner Gegend: way/1125251227#map=17/47.092825/15.717364&layers=P

Nur, wenn man in JOSM nach "Reitplatz" sucht, findet man den Preset zum Taggen von u.a. Reitplätzen nicht direkt, denn leider gibt's in JOSM keine Aliase/Synonyme und der Preset heißt "Pferdesport". In iD ist das besser, JOSM ist eben komplizierter, man muss sich mehr auskennen. Aber im Preset "Reitanlage" gibt's unten einen Link zum Preset "Pferdesport".

157502477 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1321421060 ist keine Reitanlage (leisure=horse_riding); das ist eine Führanlage (wie man auf den versch. Luftbildern sieht); dafür gibt es das Tag osm.wiki/DE:Tag:animal=horse_walker

157435090 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1320461270 and way/1320461271 are no riding centres, they are riding arenas. In OSM riding arenas are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian; compare leisure=horse_riding
They may belong to a riding centre which in this case can be mapped as a separate object (node or area), like here: way/243744278#map=18/43.676935/11.445329&layers=P

157468890 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1320767131 is a riding arena/ring and not a riding center (leisure=horse_riding). In OSM rising arenas/rings are usually tagged leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, example: way/1228324917

157364519 about 1 year ago

Hi,
way/1320020873 is surely not a horse riding centre; it is too small for that. It is probably a round pen, and round pens are usually tagged like riding arenas: leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. Similar case: way/1234386940/history
Also way/1320020872 does not really look like a horse riding centre; but I am not sure from the imagary what it is. Anyway, leisure=horse_riding "... is for the whole area which may contain one or more riding arenas, stables, riding halls, other related buildings or paddocks" (from leisure=horse_riding), like here: way/1319870274