Hufkratzer's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 127929122 | about 3 years ago | Hi, you have tagged way/1106112671 as St Patrick's Way Stables, but this area is just a riding arena. According to the wiki riding arenas shoud be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian instead of leisure=horse_riding (see leisure=horse_riding). I would recommend to map St Patrick's Way Stables as a separate feature (area or node). Here is an example that demonstrates the difference between riding arenas and riding centres/stables from near Belfast: way/641583388 |
| 127626188 | about 3 years ago | Hi, imho way/1104463990 looks like a typical outdoor riding arena and therefore should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (see info box on top of leisure=horse_riding). |
| 127856924 | about 3 years ago | Thanks for adding back the building tag; compare https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/9104#issuecomment-1286186627 But what you have now tagged with leisure=horse_riding is not the whole centre/farm either but just their outdoor arena (carrière) and should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian instead (see info box on top of osm.wiki/FR:Tag:leisure=horse_riding). Compare these correct examples for using the tags from your region:
|
| 127846074 | about 3 years ago | Hi, you have removed the building tag from way/224232876 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding . In the aerial view it looks like a building. A building should have a building tag. Also the horse_riding tag should not be used for a specific building but for the whole area (including riding arenas, etc,), see leisure=horse_riding . If you don't know the extension of the area you can add a node with leisure=horse_riding, osm.wiki/Tag:name=..., osm.wiki/Tag:website=... instead. |
| 127631988 | about 3 years ago | Hallo, es ist unsinnig, bei den ganzen Gebäuden das building=yes durch leisure=horse_riding zu ersetzen. Erstens sollte jedes Gebäude ein building-Tag haben, egal, wofür es benutz wird, und zweitens ist das Tag leisure=horse_riding nicht für spezielle Gebäude, sondern (einmalig) für die gesamte Gelände der Reitanlage, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding. Das gesamte Gelände wäre in diesem Fall vermutlich way/92537361, welches vor einem Jahr mal jemand als leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian getaggt hat, was normalerweise für Reitplätze verwendet wird und hier daher auch unsinnig ist. |
| 127497754 | about 3 years ago | Hi, you have removed the building tag from way/825331404 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding . In the aerial view it looks like a building. A building should have a building tag. Also the horse_riding tag should not be used for a specific building but for the whole farm, see leisure=horse_riding .
|
| 127466800 | about 3 years ago | Hi,
|
| 127541043 | about 3 years ago | Hi, why did you tag way/1103925576 with leisure=horse_riding? This tag is for riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding) but on bing it looks like a riding arena and riding arenas should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena). Please take into account the different meanings of the tags; here is an example from your region that demonstrates them: way/920995188 |
| 127470541 | about 3 years ago | Hi, can it be that you have confused some tags on the ways way/1103528823 and way/1103528824 ? The tag combination leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian is generally used for riding arenas (areas where horses are exercised), and the tag leisure=horse_riding should be used for riding centers, compare leisure=horse_riding and way/579337172 |
| 127283343 | about 3 years ago | Hi, wieso hast du way/1102512825 mit leisure=horse_riding getaggt? Das sieht doch eher aus wie ein einfacher Reitplatz. Nach dem Wiki sollte ein Reitplatz die Tags leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian bekommen (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz), und Anfang des Jahres hast du ja auch einige Reitplätze als pitche getaggt (z.B. way/1025134325). Also wie kommt dieser Sinneswandel? Das betrifft auch way/1085249868 (von vor 2 Monaten). |
| 127254636 | about 3 years ago | Hi, you have tagged way/1102363937 with leisure=horse_riding. Are you sure it is a riding centre (leisure=horse_riding) and not just a round riding arena (leisure=pitch#Riding_arena)? |
| 127162533 | about 3 years ago | |
| 127162533 | about 3 years ago | Hi, why did you tag way/1101779402 with leisure=horse_riding? This tag is for riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding) but it looks more like a riding arena (typical size 20x40m) and riding arenas should be tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena). You have already tagged some of them correctly in the past, e.g. way/751328536. But other arenas you have tagged as riding centres, e.g.
|
| 127094424 | about 3 years ago | Hi, way/1101451033 looks like a riding arena (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view, but you have tagged it with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). You have already tagged riding arenas correctly earlier:
And way/1101451032 isn't a riding centre either but may be a covered horse walker, see animal=horse_walker |
| 126936890 | about 3 years ago | Habe es jetzt in deinem Auftrag erledigt. |
| 127017260 | about 3 years ago | Hi, you have tagged way/1100949264 as a riding center (tag leisure=horse_riding) but in the aerial view to me it looks more like a riding arena (leisure=pitch#Riding_arena). In the iD editor there are two different presets for them ("Horseback Riding Center" and "Horseback Riding Arena"). |
| 126936890 | about 3 years ago | Hier auch:
|
| 126936890 | about 3 years ago | Hintergrund: Du hast den Reitplatz (way/1100610976) nicht als Reitplatz getaggt, sondern als Reitanlage (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding) |
| 126936890 | about 3 years ago | Hi, way/1100610976 ist vermutlich (Luftbild, Größe) eher ein (kleiner) Reitplatz (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz). In JOSM ist der Preset dafür leider nur etwas umständlich zu finden: Suche z.B. nach "pferd", dann kommt Preset "Pferdesport" und da kann man "Reitplatz" auswählen. |
| 126757010 | about 3 years ago | done, see changeset/126961379 |