Hufkratzer's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 125416426 | over 3 years ago | Hi, why did you tag way/1089513278 as leisure=horse_riding and way/1089529589 as leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian? They look similar in the aerial view. I wonder if leisure=horse_riding is appropriate for such a flat area, compare wiki. |
| 125319305 | over 3 years ago | You have removed the building tag from way/597148944, but it looks like a building in the aerial view. |
| 125045340 | over 3 years ago | Ein einzelner Reitplatz ist aber keine Reitanlage (leisure=horse_riding), so wie im Wiki beschrieben.
|
| 125017538 | over 3 years ago | Hi, I had a look on the website from node/9959241690. Thsi doesn't seem to be a horse racing track. Possible Alternative: leisure=horse_riding + sport=equestrian, see leisure=horse_riding |
| 125038274 | over 3 years ago | Hi, way/1087094564 seems to be the indoor of arena (a building) of Moorlands Equestrian Centre (node/6783641323), but it has no building tag. The tag leisure=horse_riding should be used only once for the whole riding centre (see leisure=horse_riding) and we already have the node for that. An alternative tag for the building may be building=riding_hall |
| 125045340 | over 3 years ago | Hi, way/1087131724 sieht im Luftbild aus wie ein Reitplatz, den würde ich auch als Reitplatz taggen, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz . Mir scheint, du taggst Reitplätze meistens mit leisure=horse_riding, aber dieses Tag ist für komplette Reitanlagen/reiterhöfe incl. Stall usw. siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding. |
| 125004181 | over 3 years ago | Hi, mapping 2 nested leisure=horse_riding like way/1086882872 inside of way/783037402 makes no sense, compare leisure=horse_riding. I assume the small inner one is a riding arena and should be tagged as leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena |
| 124913444 | over 3 years ago | Hi, you have removed the building tag from way/366750308/history and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding. This object looks like a building in the aerial view, therefore I assume it was not intended to remove the building tag. The horse_riding tag is for the whole area of the ranch, not just for one building, see leisure=horse_riding and way/1066610101 |
| 124918901 | over 3 years ago | Hi, I think way/1086378526 looks like a riding arena (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view, but you have tagged it with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). I wonder why you did that because some months ago you have already tagged some riding arenas correctly, e.g. way/1056273503 |
| 124867787 | over 3 years ago | Hi, way/1086077023 sieht im Luftbild typisch aus wie ein Reitplatz, den würde ich als Reitplatz taggen, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz . Im iD einfach "Reitplatz" eingeben und auswählen. Das Reitanlagen-Tag (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding) ist für eine komplette Anlage incl. Stall usw. geeignet. |
| 124793779 | over 3 years ago | Hi, why did you change the tagging from leisure=pitch to leisure=horse_riding? It looks like a riding arena in the aerial view and the wiki recommends leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian for riding arenas, see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena. Tag leisure=horse_riding (leisure=horse_riding) is for the whole area of a riding centre, example: way/365673006 |
| 124712743 | over 3 years ago | Hi, way/1085253785 was tagged with leisure=horse_riding (see leisure=horse_riding), but in the aerial view it looks more like a riding arena, see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena |
| 124689487 | over 3 years ago | Hi, you have removed the building tag from way/667777448/history and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding. This object looks like a building in the aerial view, therefore I assume it was not intended to remove the building tag. Maybe it is a riding hall / indoor arena (building=riding_hall). The horse_riding tag is not appropriate for buildings, it is for complete riding centres, see leisure=horse_riding and some better examples in this region: way/290510928 and way/1004974558 |
| 124594464 | over 3 years ago | You have only corrected one of the three. area=yes is not necessary for pitches. There is a preset for riding arenas, but in Spanish the name is "Picadero". Maybe this should be changed (compare discussion: osm.wiki/ES_talk:Tag:leisure=pitch), or, at least, some aliases should be added so that iD finds this preset if one searches for "pista de equitación" or similar. |
| 124594334 | over 3 years ago | I agree :) |
| 124594334 | over 3 years ago | There is a node for "Yeguada La Cruz" from 2 years ago: node/7065003329 , so that it is currently mapped twice. |
| 124594464 | over 3 years ago | leisure=track + sport=horse_racing is not an appropriate tagging for
|
| 124631128 | over 3 years ago | Hi, way/1084606956 ist ein Roundpen. Den würde ich als kleinen Reitplatz taggen, also so wie den größeren Reitplatz daneben, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz . Im iD einfach "Roundpen" eingeben und auswählen. Das Reitanlagen-Tag (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding) wäre eher für die komplette Anlage incl. Reitplatz, Stall usw. geeignet, was in diesem Fall vermutlich https://www.reitgarten-thekla.de/der-reitgarten wäre. Vgl. anderes Beispiel in der Nähe: way/333154306 |
| 124472877 | over 3 years ago | Hi, I think way/1083747632 looks like a riding arena (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view, but you have tagged it with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). |
| 124525683 | over 3 years ago | way/164461105 looks like a building in the aerial views, but it has no building tag. And the horse_riding tag is not appropriate for buildings. Why didn't you map the riding centre like you did in way/1080224424 and in way/1080228633 two weeks ago? |