OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
124315279 over 3 years ago

Hi,
way/367450938/history
and
way/367450939/history
look like riding arenas in the aerial view (the small one like a roundpen); they are usually tagged with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena), and there are 2 other riding arenas tagged this way not far away:
way/579996653
and
way/914483344.

But you have tagged the areas with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding).
I wonder why you did that because a year ago you have (re)tagged several riding arenas correctly:
way/892632653/history
way/915643331/history
way/915946932
way/915946933
way/931390566

124263406 over 3 years ago

Hi, way/1082492537 and way/1082492561 look like roundpens, which are usually tagged like very small riding arenas (see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena), but you have tagged them with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). In this case the riding centre is probably the whole "Grunt Galatik" / http://www.gruntgalatik.cz . Compare: way/945872752

124249790 over 3 years ago

Excuse me; I have now changed the second one myself.

124249790 over 3 years ago

Hi, way/1082419622 and also way/307506828 from 6 months ago look like riding arenas (leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view, but they are tagged with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding).

124220338 over 3 years ago

Hi, way/1050235443 looks like a riding arena in the aerial view, but it is tagged with leisure=horse_riding (leisure=horse_riding). In case you don't know this yet: there is a preset "riding arena" in iD that sets more appropriate tags for riding arenas (leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, compare leisure=pitch#Riding_arena)

124161418 over 3 years ago

Hi, you have removed the building tag from way/74711696 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding . This object looks like a building in the aerial view, therefore I assume it was not intended to remove the building tag. Maybe it is a riding hall / indoor arena (building=riding_hall). The horse_riding tag is not appropriate for buildings, it is for complete riding centres, see leisure=horse_riding and some better examples in this region: way/32128201 , way/537192242 and way/1018938003

124156936 over 3 years ago

Hi, way/1081891482 sieht mir eher wie ein Reitplatz aus, den würde ich als Reitplatz taggen, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz . Im iD einfach "Reitplatz" eingeben und auswählen. Das Reitanlagen-Tag (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding) wäre eher für eine komplette Anlage incl. Stall usw. geeignet.

123973687 over 3 years ago

way/1080735257 clearly looks like a riding arena (leisure=pitch#Riding_arena) in the aerial view and should be tagged as such, rather than with leisure=horse_riding, which is for complete riding centres (see leisure=horse_riding). The horse_riding tag rather belongs to way/1080735258 together with the name and website from way/356676531 , like here: way/779725190

123981220 over 3 years ago

You have removed the building tag from way/244367674 and replaced it with leisure=horse_riding . This object looks like a building in the aerial view, therefore I assume it was not intended to remove the building tag. Maybe it is a riding hall / indoor arena (building=riding_hall). The horse_riding tag is not appropriate for buildings, it is for complete riding centres, see leisure=horse_riding ; better example in this region: way/245104833

123891571 over 3 years ago

Reithallen (way/635165196) und Reitplätze (way/1080267024) sind keine Reitanlagen, sie können höchstens auf dem Gelände einer Reitanlage sein. Auf osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding steht extra: "Verwende das Tag nur einmalig für die gesamte Reitanlage, verwende es nicht mehrfach an verschiedenen zugehörigen Objekten". Für Reitplätze (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz) gibt es in iD ein Preset "Reitplatz"; für Reithallen gibt es noch keins, aber eine Wiki-Seite: osm.wiki/DE:Tag:building=riding_hall

123735800 over 3 years ago

way/1079313105 is the outdoor riding arena of the hotel nearby (can be seen in the video from their website); riding arenas should be tagged with leisure=pitch, see leisure=pitch#Riding_arena and not with leisure=horse_riding (= riding centre).

123670098 over 3 years ago

Hi, falls es sich bei way/1078916707 und way/1078916708 um Reitplätze handelt (was ich nach den Luftbildern stark vermute) wäre ein entsprechendes Tagging als osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz sinnvoller.

123626836 over 3 years ago

Sorry for bothering you, I will retag this myself then,

123624935 over 3 years ago

You have removed the building tags from way/993666667 and way/1015324733 and replaced them with leisure=horse_riding . These objects look like buildings in the aerial view, therefore I assume it was not intended to remove the building tags. And the horse_riding tag is not really appropriate for buildings, it is for the whole riding centre, see leisure=horse_riding . I have seen mappers doing this several times recently and wonder why they do it. Maybe there should be some warning in iD.

123626836 over 3 years ago

I think, the horse_riding tag is inappropriate for a manege; a better tag would be leisure=sports_hall, see wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:building=riding_hall and leisure=sports_hall#Examples . The horse_riding tag is for the whole equestrian centre (see leisure=horse_riding), but in this case this is already tagged as sports_centre.

123340683 over 3 years ago

You are not the only one who did that. Yes, the horse_riding tag can be put on the farmyard area like it is done in the example on the wiki page, then it contains the riding hall and the stable. But on their websites they write that they also have an outdoor riding arena of 25 x 50 m. This is not mapped yet. If someone maps it, the horse_riding area should be extended so that it contains the outdoor arena, because this also belongs to the whole facility.

123492736 over 3 years ago

Wenn du schon dran schreibst name=Reitplatz (und er sieht ja im Luftbild auch so aus) dann würde ich ihn auch als Reitplatz taggen, siehe osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=pitch#Reitplatz . Im iD einfach "Reitplatz" eingeben und auswählen. Das Reitanlagen-Tag (osm.wiki/DE:Tag:leisure=horse_riding) wäre eher für die gesamte Anlage incl. Stall und Paddocks geeignet.

123340683 over 3 years ago

Hi. Why did you remove the building tag from this building? Isn't there a building anymore? I assume this is the riding hall / indoor arena which is described on https://www.ruitersclub-saeftinghe.be and http://www.ruitersclubsaeftinghe.be/Welkom.html . The tag leisure=horse_riding is not for a building, it is for the whole facility described on these websites (including all the other stuff, especially the outdoor arena which is not mapped yet, compare leisure=horse_riding) So the node was more appropriate for this whole facility. For the tagging for the riding hall / indoor arena see building=riding_hall

123311700 over 3 years ago

way/1076536540 looks like a riding arena to me in the aerial view, but you tagged it with leisure=horse_riding. Please have a look at the wiki page for this tag (leisure=horse_riding) and check if this is really the right tag for this area. 4 months ago you tagged a similar area (way/1038702581) with leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian, which is normally used for riding arenas and recommended in the wiki (leisure=pitch#Riding_arena). Also the other areas that you have tagged with leisure=horse_riding seem to be only riding arenas. The use of the tag leisure=horse_riding seems to be quite confused in your country in general, I couldn't find a good example there showing the difference between leisure=horse_riding (riding centre) and leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian (riding arena). Here is one from the Leningrad region: way/536620374 .

123211203 over 3 years ago

Nach der Website vom RFV Legelshurst scheint way/1075911825 der Turnierplatz zu sein. Wenn das stimmt, sollte der nicht mit leisure=horse_riding gataggt werden, sondern mit leisure=pitch + sport=equestrian. Dafür gibt es in iD den Preset mit Namen "Reitplatz". leisure=horse_riding steht für eine komplette Reitanlage, in diesem Fall die Reitanlage vom RFV. Wenn der Turnierplatz dazu gehört, sollte man die Fläche dieser Reitanlage (way/707989865) so vergrößern, dass sie den Turnierplatz mit einschließt.