Glassman's Comments
| Post | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Brampton Address Import & Conflation | It would be great to see an import of addresses (and buildings, if possible) for Brampton. But please make sure to comply with the requirements to use CC By 4.0 in OSM |
|
| Skyway.run: Mapping Downtown Minneapolis | I love this project. Years ago, in the middle of winter, I moved to Eden Prairie and worked downtown. Every day I walk the skyways for lunch and shopping. Then, one nice spring day, I decided to walk back outside after having lunch. Got LOST! Had to go back into the skyway system to find my way back to work! Good luck with your project and building a community. Check to see if there are OSGeo group or people interested. I’m not sure if OSM US funds Meetup, but if so, that is a great way to get people interested. |
|
| GTFS to OSM GO Sync | I assume you are talking about https://github.com/reubot/gtfs-osm-sync. I haven’t tried it but fortunately I live in a rural area. |
|
| New validation rule: Suspicious addr:state value | Thanks for fixing those in Canada. I could say something about becoming the 51st state, but who needs that xxx |
|
| Wheelchair Accessibility Mapping in Regina - Some Thoughts | @Pieter Vander Vennet Check out AccessMap.app. It routes via elevators inside of buildings. For example, in downtown Seattle, where the streets are steep, as well as at light rail stations. |
|
| Wheelchair Accessibility Mapping in Regina - Some Thoughts | It is a shame that the mall doesn’t have elevators for people with mobility issues. I’ve been mapping sidewalks as separate ways for some time. I got started after working with the University of Washington Taskar Center Accessible Technology. The Taskar center even has a great map tool, AccessMap.app. It likely because the Taskar Center is located in Seattle that they created such a great map tool. Seattle is a very hilly city. So AccessMap.app will even direct wheelchair users to elevators during opening hours. If you get Regina sidewalks map, let the Taskar Center know so they can add your city to their map. OSM US is also has a Pedestrian Working Group. We hope to have a sidewalk map done in the near future. |
|
| Removing spam from OpenStreetMap: What is anti-SEO aktion? | The NeisBot account of Pascal Neis seems to be identifying SEO edits. Having a tools that could accurately flag SEO edits that are being done without following the Organized Editing Guidelines would be nice. Then those edits could be reverted until the SEO complies with our requirements. For now, I’d be happy if someone could identify those SEO edits that use a user name similar to the company being added so they could be reverted. Is there a publication that SEO firms read? We could write an article explaining how we plan to revert any unauthorized SEO edit will just be reverted. I used to know someone who worked for an SEO in Seattle, but that was so long ago that the contact info is lost. |
|
| Vancouver Island woodland project completed | Wow - amazing work. I struggled just working in a small area in Washington State. (just to the south of Vancouver Island to those not familiar.) Like you, I noticed the impact on my fingers. Last I read there are just a few glaciers left on Vancouver Island. Did you map any of those? Other than glaciers at higher elevations, like those in the Cascade Mountain Range, did you notice if they are significantly smaller than what government data sets show? |
|
| Swissvale Sidewalks | You might want to include adding stop signs if missing and if there are tactile pads. |
|
| Minutely Shortbread tiles | Your vector tiles project is set to become one of the best major improvements to OpenStreetMap. As @Minh said - excitement is an understatement. Keep up the great work. |
|
| How I Map Streams and Wetlands | @mycota - are you in Arizona? I spent some time in Tucson. My contacts with the county GIS were unproductive. I would recommend getting to know your local city/county GIS department. When I started mapping I didn’t know anyone, but now I’m good friends with a number of them. And tomorrow I’m going to the local GIS breakfast. I say this because they can make waivers to use their data in OSM. |
|
| How I Map Streams and Wetlands | Snohomish County data is in the public domain - except when it includes personal information, such as assessor records. Since personal data isn’t appropriate for OSM it shouldn’t be used. The rest of the data is in the public domain. |
|
| How I Map Streams and Wetlands | Thanks for posting on mapping streams and wetlands. I’m in the county just north of Snohomish and plan to figure out how to map wetlands. The stream data from the state/county is good, but the wetlands could use more work. There are a number around me that the state hasn’t identified. BTW - a few years ago I worked with Marysville GIS department to map buildings and addresses. I’m sure it needs updating with all the new developments. If you are interested I can try to find the name of the person from the city I worked with. Melody Ovard is in the county’s GIS department and has been very helpful. The Snohomish County GIS manager comes to a lot of GIS events in the area. Let me know if there is anything I can do to help. Clifford |
|
| OSM Turned 19, See How It Transformed Me! | Hawa, Thanks for posting your wonderful OpenStreetMap story. And to my friend Geoffrey - thanks for your inspiration. |
|
| Sidewalk mapped separately | I started out mapping sidewalks as a road attribute but discovered that it doesn’t work for sidewalk routing. Mapping sidewalks as separate footways solves that problem. While OSM may have started mapping roads, there is a portion of the population that uses footways to get around. This is especially important for people with limited mobility. Knowing where kerb cuts exits is very important to people with limited mobility. Mapping footways as separate footways solves that problem. Plus - trying to route yourself on Google. If there are stair involved, Google fails miserably. Probably because there is no money to be made. OSM solves that problem. Mapping footways as separate ways is more difficult, but it does pay off in the end. Check out osm.wiki/Sidewalks Happy Mapping, |
|
| Finding SEO spam in OSM | One easy method of finding SEO Spam is to review new users contributions. Since the main culprits seem to limit their changesets to one or two, they show up as a new users. Around me, they show up with a changeset comment of updated and have a username much like the business being added. I would encourage everyone to start welcoming new users in their area using the Welcome tool. I would also like to thank user_53959 for their world wide work of cleaning up SEO Spam. When the changeset has many errors, I usually just revert the edit. Otherwise I try to fix minor issues. Over the years I’ve tried contacting businesses to find out who is adding their business to OSM. So far no luck. |
|
| A new home to OSMCha | Wille, I want to thank you and the rest of the developers that work on OSMCha. It has been my goto tool for years. I look forward to seeing the new features you and your team develop. Best, Clifford |
|
| Women Participation in OpenStreetMap: Perspectives of all Genders | I started answering the survey but discovered that most of the answers are open-ended questions. I would recommend, if you didn’t already do so, that you conduct a forum to help create mostly closed-ended questions. Open-ended questions are great for getting detail but limit analytical abilities. Tools like Telegram or Slack are great for conducting forums to gather your initial data to create more closed-end questions. This is an important topic which I hope gets plenty of attention. Best, Clifford |
|
| organicmaps | You can see the bounding box of your edits by looking at your history. Just go to your profile and click on my edits. Link below to speed the process. One edit appears to cover a wide area but the rest look good. |
|
| Apple Data Team #ADT multiplying Nodes on Coastlines | Wow - the work they did looks great. They are welcome to improve coastlines around me. Disclaimer, while I know some of the Apple team members, I’m not involved in their work, which they wouldn’t tell me about anyway. |