Glassman's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 161008141 | 12 months ago | Please make sure the source you used isn't copyrighted and can not be used in OSM.
|
| 161007457 | 12 months ago | #TIP: when removing a business, also remove the associated tags, in this case soport=karting. But leave the address tags as they will likely be reused as you did in this case.
|
| 160968686 | 12 months ago | Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it looks good.
|
| 160963382 | 12 months ago | #TIP: when removing a business, leave the address tags since they can be reused by the next business.
|
| 160935209 | 12 months ago | Great work adding in all the sidewalks. Here is a couple of suggestions. A roof features needs the layer=1 tag so that service roads can go under the roof. When you updated the name of the gas station, you removed the address. Those address are nice to have in OSM. Addresses are typically reused even when buildings are torn down. Both the roof and addresses have been fixed. I'll send you more info on OSM in a message.
|
| 160924487 | 12 months ago | #TIP: we spell out street names in OSM. The reason is that software has a hard time unabbreviating. Also the street you added in your other edit, should be a driveway as noted on county gis records. These have been fixed by another contributor. I'll send you more info on OSM in a message.
|
| 160899856 | 12 months ago | This app requires that I review everything as good or bad. There is no in between. When I mark it as bad, it may only be that it doesn't fit the OSM tagging scheme. I'll leave a changeset comment with what I found. the majority of tags do not even come close to OSM standards. Reverting
|
| 161027974 | 12 months ago | You changed landuse=residential to landuse=grass then in the next changeset you deleted all of the landuse areas. Can you add the landuse back? Let me know if you need help.
|
| 161027974 | 12 months ago | You changed landuse=residential to landuse=grass then in the next changeset you deleted all of the landuse areas. Can you add the lanuse back? Let me know if you need help.
|
| 161039486 | 12 months ago | I noticed you are adding farmland which is great, but typically farmland doesn't have a name, such as field 1. Also, farmland should only cover the crop area, and not the farm yard. Farm yards are tagged as landuse=farmyard. The trees you mapped as landuse=forest, is likely just natural=wood. I fixed one of them. I would strongly suggest you consult the wiki for example landuse=farmland. you might also want to join the OSM US Slack at osmus.slack.com where you can get help contributing to OSM.
|
| 160460033 | 12 months ago | OSM spells out street names. The reason is that software has a hard time unabbreviating. Can you please restore the names of all the street you changed? Thanks
|
| 160380592 | 12 months ago | Thank you for your edit. I reviewed your work and it looks good. I see you changed the name in a subsequent edit. Thanks.
|
| 160892407 | 12 months ago | This app requires that I review everything as good or bad. There is no in between. When I mark it as bad, it may only be that it doesn't fit the OSM tagging scheme. I'll leave a changeset comment with what I found. please read the wiki on how to add your business to OSM. You might want to start with shop=computer. Also your address is the same as another business in the same building, including suite number. I'm going to remove the non standard tags so hopefully you will add the correct ones.
|
| 160848919 | 12 months ago | The location is in a parking lot. Is the actual location just to the north in the Carrara building? Also, is the office really open 24/7? |
| 160838828 | 12 months ago | Thanks for the info and yes I'm aware of the wiki page. But can you explain why West Barlett Road was upgraded from residential to Tertiary? It doesn't have a shoulder and just has the default county speed limit. And that is just one example of my concern. Can I suggest you discuss these edits on OSM US Slack #local_washington channel or on the OSM community forum at https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/us/ before making more changes?
|
| 160840727 | 12 months ago | Thanks - It possible that Bing image is older and the gate installed later. |
| 160838828 | 12 months ago | Why all the road upgrading? For example looks like a residential or unclassified road according to OSM classification system. A tertiary is defined as one that links smaller towns and villages. Can you explain your reasoning?
|
| 160840727 | 12 months ago | Bing street side imagery doesn't show a gate. Where is it located?
|
| 155676132 | 12 months ago | The DWG received a request to remove the Taint trail for being very unsafe. Another user agreed that it is very unsafe. Since you added this trail, would you agree that it should be removed? |
| 160804382 | 12 months ago | Looks like AwFi removed those tags. I may have to revisit the revert perl script to see why it doesn't remove everything. Thanks for the heads up. |