Hi, I've removed the duplicate railway line you added heading to DM Beith, as it is disused: https://www.geograph.org.uk/photo/4255505

I don't think these places should be marked as towns just because they were royal burghs.

St Monans and Pittenweem are normally referred to as villages, and that is consistent with other similar sized places on the map.

Hi, the three banks were already marked as individual nodes, so I've removed the duplicate tags that you added to the buildings.
Also worth seeing whether the RBS branch closes in the new year as mentioned here: http://www.eastlothiancourier.com/news/15696176.Two_RBS_branches_set_to_close/

Hi, why have you changed this to a motorway?

Hi David,
Can I ask why you have added the tags name="path continues" and tourism=attraction to almost 200 nodes?
For example here: node/4943171886
Thanks

Hi, there's two Co-ops mapped here, as both supermarket and convenience - which one is correct?

Hi, not sure if you're aware but the correct tag for a "football" pitch is sport=soccer, I've fixed this one: way/505591477

I've improved the school tagging by adding "construction:" :)

The green gym is tagged as a sports_centre but I doubt that's appropriate - probably a fitness_station or playground instead?

Just to let you know that I've changed this line way/464533061 and others around it to the more used man_made=cutline

Presumably this section should be a part of the E/W relation? relation/5880467

Hi, did you survey the Clyde Arc before you made the change to oneway=yes? Because the previous changeset said it was two parallel two way roads: way/4287346/history

Yeah, if it's not a dock then the coastline should continue into the harbour. I've left the landuse=harbour area where it is, but also added the coastline around it.

If it's not open then I'd suggest using landuse=construction and construction:amenity=school instead, so it doesn't appear on the map as an active school.
Also saw this way/286745753/history - do you know what it is and if it's open yet?

Hi, does the harbour have a gate at its entrance and is it tidal?

Hi, welcome to OSM and thanks for the edit. Just wondering if you meant to change this from a path to coastline - as it definitely looks like a path to me.

Hi, does this path way/545871315 connect to the road?

Andrew,
Even if this was a park (which it isn't) then the question is why have you just changed this one garden to a park? Are the gardens either side not also parks or is there something special about this one?
See leisure=park
Also, is the public bookcase that you added inside or outside of the Phoenix Club?

Hi, for roundabouts like this: way/545375954 you should tag them with junction=roundabout instead of oneway=yes :)

Removed

Hi, these parks you've added seem like someone's front garden to me - and are there really two lakes there on the ground?