OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
37273937 over 3 years ago

Hi
You've tag a few waterway=yes in this area. Any idea what type they are it would be great if you could get them to render.

https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1jR0

118393015 over 3 years ago

Hi
natural=grass is depreciated.
For meadows would surface or crop be better?
natural=*

122408866 over 3 years ago

'Recreation ground' tag makes no implication of accessibility.
'sport=multi' can be added to 'recreation ground' so show that many different sports are played on individual pitches.

As, by your own admittance, "The markings change throughout the year" shows that it not a pitch.

From the 'pitch' wiki page: "Pitches may be contained within a larger recreation_ground,"

A "multiple sports pitch" is for sports played within the *same* white line boundary, as noted.

leisure=pitch#Multi-sport_pitch

So what if "amenity=school doesn’t mention recreation ground anywhere"? It doesn't mean they can't be added.

The recreation ground’s page makes no mention of it being "publicly accessible". In fact it states the opposite.

Children playing sport is "general recreation".

not "having any forms of playground equipment within their borders" is irrelevant.

Given the close association of other leisures features such as pitch
park, playground, sports_centre, fitness_dtation, seating, dog park etc I firmly believe it should be tagged as leisure. leisure=recreation_ground renders on OSM-Carto

White line pitches "from different times of the year" can all be mapped, even if they overlap, such as cricket & football pitches.

None of your arguments prove your point.

79198726 over 3 years ago

Hi
What is this?
way/760831355#map=15/57.6063/-3.5897

123049708 over 3 years ago

Hi
way/1074843285
Please don't attached polygon ways to highways. Highways represent the infinitesimally narrow centreline of the road. Always set the polygons back to their boundary at the side of the road.

Imagine you wanted to add a gate to the meadow, it would mean you mapped it on the actual road, which of course isn't how it is in the real world.

122408866 over 3 years ago

Hi
way/1069295371
What pitch is that size & shape.
Pitches are for individual sports contained within white lines.
This is a recreation ground.

121370571 over 3 years ago

Hi
"Modified the tags for the landuse polygon #tomtom"

Could you clarify what lead you to duplicate the surface tag by adding landuse. Was the a validator in JOSM or TomTom prompting you?

119874928 over 3 years ago

Hi
Why have you deleted valid roller_coaster=track ways & replaced them with erroneous railway tags?

106476175 over 3 years ago

It's an attraction, not a railway.

121269784 over 3 years ago

This is neither a railway or a route.
relation/14165310#map=18/52.98690/-1.88283

122840511 over 3 years ago

A bridge tag is for objects that span over other objects.

This appears to be more a raised area,of solid ground.
I would tag using landuse=railway (is all of the polygon used/owned by a railway company?)
I would add level=1 to any items within the polygon and layer=X to those that are passing over other objects.

122840511 over 3 years ago

Hi
What's this:
way/1073348157

121717336 over 3 years ago

Hi
There was a recent discussion on this subject on the tagging forum:

https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/2022-June/064808.html

Including my own opinion:

https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/2022-June/064829.html

"consider adding it, see..." means refer to the documentation to determine which is the more accurate tag to use, not add both. They are mutually exclusive.

"In such cases usual tagging is to add just leisure=park" < This is poor advice & requires amending.

I've provided a map of your edits for you to revert:
https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1jw2

122643574 over 3 years ago

This seems like a programming error in Cycle-OSM to me. I've flagged a query:

https://github.com/cyclosm/cyclosm-cartocss-style/issues/626

89978780 over 3 years ago

Hi
I'm curious: What do the Odds & Evens refer to?
way/840945937

122539599 over 3 years ago

Apologies, I wasn't paying attention,

122539599 over 3 years ago

Hi
Why have you removed valid data?
If there are better tags to use you should have change, not removed them.

121717336 over 3 years ago

Hi
Please refrain from combining these two tags.
landuse=recreation_ground
leisure=park

They are two different types of objects. They are mutually exclusive.

Is maproulette or your editor suggesting you add both tags or did you just decide yourself?

For the existing objects, what was the original tag? Have you only added recreation ground to existing parks?

122261237 over 3 years ago

Oops.
Thanks for spotting that & letting me know.

24820421 over 3 years ago

Hi
A while ago, but could you clarify what this object is?
Seems too far away from the tracks to be a railway platform.