OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
47915464 over 8 years ago

if it's at ground level & passes through a building use tunnel=building_passage:

tunnel=*#tunnel.3Dbuilding_passage

47840188 over 8 years ago

Hi again

I assume the bridge which got amended by your edit isn't that long?
way/263380345

47843756 over 8 years ago

Hi Welcome to OSM. Good additions ot the OSM dafabase.

The new path needs revised tags. If you know it's a PROW the best way to map it is:
designation=public_footpath
foot=designated
highway=footway
surface=*

Surface is used by many routers to decide which is the best way to go.

47739867 over 8 years ago

See also:
construction=*#Highways

47739867 over 8 years ago

Hi
If it's still being built it;s more accurate to ued this tag: landuse=construction

47523302 over 8 years ago

@ti-lo
I look forward discussing your proposal on the Tagging mailing list.

47523302 over 8 years ago

What are your plans to revert your erroneous edits?

PS
"These SHOULD be proposed on the tagging group!!! Not proposed on a wiki page."

47627713 over 8 years ago

Hi
Is the bridge open?

47406436 over 8 years ago

Although this entity was tagged indirectly in the first place (it should be shop not amenity), you made it worse by removing any primary tag & substituting with a sole sub-tag. Sub-tags are 'adjective' tags which help describe the details of the objects.

47523302 over 8 years ago

As explained previously you've change the meaning of the entity, not provided an alternative.

There is no 'issue' to solve. The entity was accurately & legitimately tagged before your amendments.
As you've no knowledge of this shop you should not have made any changes.

I'm 'complaining' because you reduced the accuracy of the OSM database.
It's disappointing you believe others should correct your errors & fill in ambiguities you've created.

I note another user has taken issue with your edits (which is even worse than this one).
I note you've been given a warning block.

47523302 almost 9 years ago

Hi
if I were in your position I wouldn't have made the amendments due to lack of *any* knowledge to justify the changes. Your last sentence confirms why.

shop=motorcycle_repair means it doesn't sell bikes. You've now made it, at best, ambiguous.

47523302 almost 9 years ago

Hi
"as I can't say whether it (meanwhile) possibly sells used bikes." < Again, this is the problem. You've explicitly changed it from 'definitely doesn't sell bikes' to 'definitely does sell bikes' *without* any knowledge.

47523302 almost 9 years ago

I'm unsure why you don't get my point.
Was it discussed on https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/ ?

"can't do that as my crystal ball is broken" < this is the problem. You've edited a tag from being correct to incorrect without any knowledge.
According to you're wiki edits, the way you've tagged it implies it sells motorcycles. This is not good process.

47523302 almost 9 years ago

Even if the revised tagging system is adopted (Was there any discussion?) you haven't confirmed whether it sells motorcycles or not.

47523302 almost 9 years ago

Hi ti-lo
I've notice you've changed shop=motorcycle_repair to shop=motorcycle
What source did you use to ascertain they sell motorcycles?

47285161 almost 9 years ago

Hi
I'm sure the hotel is in the correct position, but it's clashing with the existing car park. This also requires updating.

47267476 almost 9 years ago

How old is that data? This is a new build that encompasses the previous sites of a business & retirement flats. A google of BA1 1BJ returns no businesses. Isn't code point just a bit of a guess at the centroid of a rough polygon?
The site of Green Park House was tagged with a postcode from a verifiable source.

47267476 almost 9 years ago

To check, does this block have 2 postcodes? Website lists only one.

47285161 almost 9 years ago

Hi
I presume the car park has been rebuilt to accommodate?

47223910 almost 9 years ago

Hi Ashley
To double check, did you mean to delete a pier in Norway: http://osmlab.github.io/changeset-map/#47223910?