I do not need to check LiDAR to see what is there, that is just ridiculous if you map abandoned based on LiDAR because we have so many abandoned stuffs since civil war and that is equivalent to adding junks (but to be fair I don’t think you do this all the time so let’s not discuss that). Historic sign means nothing, that sign does not serve as a map and it does not tell you what the road looked like decades ago. All you added are something abandoned, but do you have any guarantee that the road looked exactly like this in the past? BTW Bing does not display any data like this, so you added them based on your imagination, which is why we call it unacceptable.

I have plenty of evidence showing nothing there that “makes you think it is something abandoned in the year of 2022”, but more like scrubs and bushes. Connecting any “abandoned” with current road is not acceptable. We have OHM, perhaps you need to move to a new place.

It is ok to draw something abandoned, but it is not ok to restore them just because there is a sign, there is a trace in LiDAR.

Many developments will make road shorter, easier to drive, aligned with terrain for better sights. If you restore them as abandoned, I’m afraid this is called vandalism.

You have been there? Please show us the evidences that can be used to identify it as an abandoned road.

I’ve been there as well, numerous of times for state parks. That does not mean anything and I don’t mention it.

Your edit of living street has been reverted:

1. Streets with 25mph limit do not automatically qualify this type, as it is common in the residential area in the US.

2. Most of the living streets in US do not open to vehicle traffic (you will see bollards / brick surfaces / blocks, because only emergency vehicles can enter), which is more found in cities/large towns. A myriad of hoods like this one in PA, can be found in every state, residential road is still the preferred type.

way/12341015/history#map=18/40.13799/-75.46914

Sorry, what is the point adding this?

How did you find an abandonded road via Bing maps?

Would you please stop adding junks when "oh I find something was there via a map made around 60 years ago"?

If that road was there long ago, it was removed to have a better driving experience, what's the point bringing it back in OSM, because of...nostalgia?

way/1049200180#map=16/41.3878/-76.2781

Why you upgraded this to primary?

way/11982897/history#map=14/41.3064/-76.7839

Are these area useful? I only see increased maintenance for future mappers and it serves no purpose to the general public. The alternative will be a single line that does the same trick.

I sincerely don't get the point. It is like mapping streets as an area. Micromapping is not a good idea here.

I may consider bulk removing this in the future.

Also, where did you get that it is paved??? Please map with care, you do not appear to have visited that place.

Please avoid adding sources tag.

way/1101384540#map=18/41.71424/-76.10594

No such thing

way/958447650/history#map=19/41.65984/-76.11829

Let's avoid adding garbage to the map.

way/1118731262#map=19/41.70615/-76.11821

Please use PEMA imagery to draw everything in Sus County.

What's the point of importing addresses into a river?

node/8793449032#map=18/42.08092/-76.06132

You are not supposed to map only with AI.

Adding a non existent bridge to suppress the warning, does not make sense.

way/910849549#map=19/41.87684/-76.08418

There is no such thing as PA-XXXX in PennDOT system.

way/175748352/history#map=19/41.82418/-75.68034

Not sure where you got that name from.

way/10720296/history#map=19/41.70079/-75.92104

Let's avoid spamming sources tag, please put in changeset comments only

Who the h* is the local user here…? And just because they requested through Mapbox, you are going to accept without validation? Who are you?

Hmm…what about changing to pedestrian area?

I plan to remove the footway polygon here. Just like highway, they do not need to be in polygon.

relation/13064460#map=18/39.40837/-76.59307

I very much agree but I think the entire building is datacenter only.

If it is wrong, feel free to correct!