Hi,
You have been adding a few admin boundaries with "source snapp". Can you please clarify what your source for these boundary ways is? I hope it is not the map of "Snapp" ride hailing app as that is Google Maps and can't be used to source boundaries.

Hi Amin,

With this and your previous changesets you kept removing the English name (in the name:en tag value). You only left the Persian name both in the name and duplicated in the name:fa tags for multiple streets. Is there a specific reason why you are removing English names?

Your fellow mapper Reza_koulivand from Borujerd also reached out to you about this multiple times over the last months and it would be very kind if you could respond.

These tracks that you have added: Are these actually marked tracks? Or is that a route you took crossing the desert on your own?
Judging from satellite imagery only part of it seem to actually be permanent tracks. The other half you were driving through the desert.

Hi,
For the name of the subway entrances please use the name of the exit, not of the station. The name of the station will be derived via the stop area relation. But the idea is that you can tell exits apart, e.g. "Weteringschans East"(Just made up, I do not know namings of the Vijzelgracht exits). Sometimes subway exits have additional references (1, 2, 3, 4 or A, B, C D) which you can add in the ref-Tag.

Can you explain why you deleted the metro station Teatros, including elevator infrastructure. Also you deleted the butcher shop nearby. I cannot see how this is related to a HotOSM project to *add* buildings, roads and water

Danke üfr den super schnellen Fix meiner Mapnote :) Hatte das eher als "note to self" hinterlassen, aber da warst du schneller.

Hi,
Can you please explain why you deleted all station nodes along metro line 5 in this changeset? You left the stop positions in an incomplete state this way.

Ofc Darbandikhan is located in Iraq, not Iran. Typo in the changeset description...

Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap,
Thank you for your contribution. There's a few things you need to be aware of:
I've seen that you have added Google Earth link as references to multiple objects. Please be aware that you cannot use any information from Google Maps or Streetview as sources for your OpenStreetMap data contributions since their license is not compatible with OSM's. You need to either rely on the satellite imagery that is available within the OSM editor you are using or survey on the ground with a GPS device or your mobile.

Secondly: You marked "Old Trails Road" as a primary road which is the road category used in OSM for important roads linking cities. From what the satellite imagery shows this looks more like a residential or even service road. Have a look at the highway documentation here to familiarize yourself with the established categories: highway=*
Finally you set the "ref" tag to "none" which should be used for the road reference number. If a road doesn't have one just omit this tag and do not set it to "none".
Would be great if you can revisit your additions and improve them according to the information above.

Happy further mapping.

Woops. Location should ofc be "Balkayalar, Turkey" - Looked at wrong side of the border here

Source was DigitalGlobe only. Forgot to remove "Local survey" 🤦‍♂️

Source for this changeset wasn't "Local survey", but DigitalGlobe imagery

Hi Kiarash,
Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across Shahreza area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.

This falls in line with a set of changesets you have been performing recently all over Iran where you have been applying maxspeed=* to whole cities. Can you please share your source for this information?
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/56717407

Hi Kiarash,
Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across Qom area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.

This falls in line with a set of changesets you have been performing recently all over Iran where you have been applying maxspeed=* to whole cities. Can you please share your source for this information?

Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across this area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.

This falls in line with a set of changesets you have been performing recently all over Iran where you have been applying maxspeed=* to whole cities. Can you please share your source for this information?
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/56719335

Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across this area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.

This falls in line with a set of changesets you have been performing recently all over Iran where you have been applying maxspeed=* to whole cities. Can you please share your source for this information?
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/56719773

Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across Tabriz area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.

This falls in line with a set of changesets you have been performing recently all over Iran where you have been applying maxspeed=* to whole cities. Can you please share your source for this information?
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/56720877

Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across Tabriz area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.

This falls in line with a set of changesets you have been performing recently all over Iran where you have been applying maxspeed=* to whole cities. Can you please share your source for this information?
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/56722110

Can you please share the source for your mass addition of maxspeed all across Tabriz area?
You should only add maxspeed once you have verified the speed restrictions "on the ground" or via street level imagery like Mapillary or OpenStreetCam.

FYI: If your intent is to add "default maxspeed" to certain highway types: This is not necessary. If the maxspeed tag is not present all OSM data consumers will automatically default to a maxspeed level adequate to the highway type in the country.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/56724343

Hallo Marinus,
Wie im Wiki Artikel ( osm.wiki/DE:Tag:highway=motorway%20junction?uselang=de ) gehen die Meinungen zum Namenstagging an Park- oder Rastplatzausfahrten auseinander. Insofern halte ich die Einleitung der Notiz "name-tag ist laut wiki falsch!" nicht ganz richtig. Soweit ich das verstehe, besteht einfach kein Konsens.

Ich gehöre zu der Fraktion, die dafür ist, den Namen der Raststätte am highway=motorway_junction zu erfassen. Mein Argument ist, dass es eben wohl eine über ein Schild benannte Ausfahrt ist. Siehe auch das Beispielbild eines Schildes im Wikipedia-Artikel: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autobahnparkplatz
In dem Sinne ist es eine Ausfahrt, aber keine Anschlussstelle. Diese Tatsache ist in meinen Augen ausreichend durch noref=yes dokumentiert.

Du kannst den Namen entfernen :) Ob es dadurch richtiger oder falscher wird ist Ansichtssache.