HI I saw that you requested a review - just wanted to drop you a quick note to let you know that these edits look great.

Excellent, Welcome to OpenStreetMap and thanks for the Edit!

Let me know if you have any questions?

No problem! - It does go against the normal principle of not duplicating data. But the address node at the "entrance" and then the "occupant" node does seem to work well especially in the center of town or for multiple occupants.

PS. Do you know about missing maps followed by Social this Thursday: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Edinburgh#Upcoming_Meetings

HNi just wanted to say Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and that you for your edits.

Let me know ifn you have any questions.

I'm also wondering on this edit if it might make more sense to use a building tag rather than the landuse. (We tend to use landuse over larger areas such as Industial Estates or Business Parks).

Hi Bruce - Welcome to OpenStreetMap. I see you requested a review and I've had a quick look over them and they look good.

Thanks for Editing and let me know if you have any questions.

I have set this back to Trunk.

HI Welcome to OpenStreetMap and thanks for the Edits. I see that you requested some feedback, and they look great to me.

My only question/suggestion is if the Hinterland Shelter should be an amenity=shelter rather than a park?
(osm.org/#map=19/57.65646/-3.58689) Let me know if you have any questions.

Cheers
Chris

So we had left this as a Trunk Road rather than as a Motorway as it won't be running under motorway restrictions until October?

oops possibly a bit overzealous, I'm going to double check things on the ground tomorrow, but I had based these roads being closed on: https://www.theforthbridges.org/plan-your-journey/road-user-guide/

Sorry this is going back a while. What source did you use for the road names, in particular Harmiston Walk?

Thanks for the changes. A changeset comment would be helpful to see what you've done.

Thanks for getting back to me. Did you see if there was an alternative route up to Den's Cleugh - I've had a look at the Strava data and it looks like it's on the other side of the wall through the woods?

Hi, just wanting to check what your source for this is? I'm pretty sure that this route does continue across here. There is evidence from the GPS trace information that this has been used.

Curious about this changeset, what is your source? also the location of the Airport 1 stop doesn't look quite right to me, for a bus stop?

Thanks, I'm guessing that you were trying to clear the view of Victoria Terrace which runs above these shops. FYI the normal convention we have in Edinburgh is for most POI's we put the POI nodes internal to the buildings with an address node inline with the building outline, and the actual entrace/address point.

I don't think that the one on Big Brigs Way is actually a roundabout? What's the evidence?

Good to see you mapping David. Hopefuly sophie won't add this back in, but if so then it might be worth keeping the node, setting it as felled tree (or similar) and making a node that the tree is felled.

Cheers
Chris

very temporary :)

On a general note, welcome to OpenStreetMap - let me know if you have any questions.

Thanks a few seconds on google would have been sufficient to determine that this is a genuine name: https://www.jupiterartland.org/artwork/suck

(especially as the Editor who added the name is a experienced editor with may changesets)

why did you remove the name of the artwork?