Hi thanks for signing up to OSM, and requesting a review. The path looks great. however it looks like it should connect to the little spur off Dunkeld Court?

Also let me know if you have any questions.

HI, welcome to OSM and thanks for requesting a review. I've had a look at the service roadyou've added and it's fine. The only improvement is to improve the curve around the corner (which I've done)

Let me know if you have any questions about editing OSM, especially in Scotland.

Cheers
Chris

For now I would add the number of disabled parking spaces to the main car park as per: amenity=parking

Adding the actual location as you have done may also be useful, though i'm not sure if anyone is using this at the moment.

I'm wondering if tagging this as a bollard with access tags as appropraite would be better?

Hi thanks for requesting a review again;l I have one small question about this small extension to the road way/744759797 - you've added it as Coach Road, but it appears to be part of Coach Close?

Thanks, for signing up and editing OSM. I see that you requested a review.

My only comment is that it isn't allways neccessary to specifically tag all the access options. access=yes access:horse=no would be sufficient, here.

let me know if you have any questions, and I look forward to seeing more mapping.

Chris

HI - welcome to OpenStreetMap; I see that you requested a review of this edit.

My main question, is about the tagging on the assumption that this a mtb tracks, or at least cycleable then I would suggest adding bicycle=designated or bicycle=yes - there are some good examples of how to do this at Glentress way/81941909

Let me know if you have any questions.

I'm not sure if these are actually directly connected? If I remember correctly, the car park is underneath, so at very least it would need to have level tags added?

Looks great! I do like the relation linking them all together as well.

I've had a small play with this as well. I moved the entrance to the right place and I think this helped simplify things up.

Hi thanks for this, I see that you requested a review. Overall the shop and the tagging look great.

It would be good to separate the shop for the car par park though.

Cheers
Chris

Cheers; this looks good. I'm wondering if we should add a historic=yes as well as some kind of building tag.

Hi - thanks for signing up to OpenStreetMap; it's great to have people map the areas's they know well. I took out the residential area as it was already covered; but have added some of the terraces.

Do they look okay?

Let me know if you have any questions?

Cheers
Chris

Thanks for adding yourselves. If you can,m the it would also be useful to add your address, as well as opening hour.

Let me know if you have any questions, and Welcome to OpenStreetMap.

HI, welcome to OSM. Thanks for requesting a review. You edit looks great, but let me know if you have any questions.

HI thanks for making these Edits. I see that you requested a review of thew edits. In general the edits looks fine; my only comment is that it shouldn't be necessary to have to add access to footpaths, routers should assume that these are good, but no harm in confirming, Let me know if you have any questions.

Cheers
Chris

I'm curious as to why you've removed these. Remmber we map as we see things rather than for the renderer?

Is this closed - not shown on the Edinburgh council roadworks page? http://edinburgh.cdmf.info/public/map/map.htm

If so what is the planned date of reopening?

Great thanks - I found the original council Traffic Redetermination Orders for these roads, and it sounds like these match up with the Imagery you have available. Thanks.

Cheers - if it's gone then probably best to go ahead and delete it. Historical objects are kept in the database, so we can get them back if we do need to and it's possible to find them.

Also let me know if you have any questions.