wtf. ANy chance you could keep to smaller areas for you changeset, 6000 nodes deleted in a single changeset is just too much,

I've fixed up the road. I appreciate the idea of George IV Bridge as an attraction. I'm just not really sure it needs an attraction tag? Wondering what the logic of adding this is?

Thanks
Chris

Brilliant thanks - one thing to note is that normally when business's closed we try and keep the node and prefix it with disused - disused=*: that way we can track the history of palces.

Thanks!

I think the layer of car park you deleted in this layer is just the ground floor of the car park rather than incorrect mapping. (possibly over zealous mapping) but I think correct?

Thanks trigpoint - think this was probably a "duplicate" of the store next to the Last Drop.

Just to be clear - I believe that you have now routed the road over a bridge that was demolished ignoring the old bridge. I'm rolling this change back before I forget to do so. See http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-34637731

Hi I just want to check what your sources for these changes are. There are lots of changes happening to the road over here and I *think* that the layout as mapped was correct?

Hi, I messaged you yesterday. Please don't remove our individually mapped trees and replace them with rows are areas?

Hi, I was just wondering what your source for this change is?

Why have you removed the trees that were individually mapped and replaced them with a forest area?

Great job - these has been a bit of a discussion on the mailing list about co-ordinating efforts to cover the 20mph zones, - https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-scotland/2017-March/thread.html

We are using the tasking mangager to comment/mark which areas have been updated or not. Mostly the plan is to make sure we don't duplicate effort and cover all the areas. The tasking manager is here: http://tasks.openstreetmapscotland.org/

Thanks!

No problem with the delay at all Dan - it's great to have you on board! and thanks for the detailed reply about the pond - it's these extra details that make OSM great!

No need for this to be on the aerial imagery a best guess from local knowledge is fine!

I have to agree it is very addictive!

How do you know this is a roundabout? I think it's just a road that ends with a circle?

Thanks Dan - I will try and get over there and have a look. We try and be better than Google Maps.

Hi I just wanted to welcome you to OpenStreetMap - I've been trying to find a way of validating this edit - But I just wanted to check how you know there is a pond here.

As it's very unusual to see ponds in tenement gardens?

Let me know if you have any questions.

Hi Dan, I would just like to start by welcoming you to OpenStreetMap - from your comment, it sounds like this is a private road, therefore should it be tagged as private rather than deleted?

Thanks CHris

Apologies just noticed that you fixed up the name. All good!

Why - The name of the premises is Buckstone Terrace Post Office - so possibly move Post Office to brand? But don't delete the name entirely?