Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 71034818 | over 6 years ago | The section of Conklin Road you added looks pretty "former" to me. If you switch over to Esri World Imagery (a few months older than DigitalGlobe Premium, but much sharper), you'll see a fallen log that looks like it's been there for a while, and a couple of trees that are probably 5-10 years old. |
| 70972003 | over 6 years ago | The "residential road" tag you used for the roads you added down by Walla Walla is intended for things like house-lined suburban streets. A better tag for what you added is "driveway". (Historically, "residential road" has also been used as the default tag for "you can drive here" features, so it's difficult to learn the proper usage of it from looking at the map.) |
| 70938928 | over 6 years ago | Please don't use abbreviations in names. It's easy for a computer to abbreviate a word if it needs to save space, but going the other direction is much harder. For example, should "St" be expanded to "Street", "State", or "Saint"? |
| 70915792 | over 6 years ago | Has Horse Haven been re-opened? Last I heard, it was very much an abandoned airstrip. |
| 70838259 | over 6 years ago | Is there a reason you deleted the driveway here? It sure looks like it exists in the aerial imagery. |
| 70763151 | over 6 years ago | If you're going to do a Maproulette task, please actually *do* the task. If a driveway is misaligned and mis-tagged, marking it as "looks okay" doesn't count. |
| 70761376 | over 6 years ago | Please don't mark a road that doesn't exist as "looks okay". |
| 70759215 | over 6 years ago | Please don't mark non-existent roads as "looks okay". |
| 70466926 | over 6 years ago | The historic map you're citing here is a plat map, not a road map. It shows how the land is subdivided for ownership, and where space is reserved for building roads, but not where roads are actually built. For an example of why plat maps aren't useful for mapping roads, consider this map: http://www.historicmapworks.com/Map/US/37807/Spokane+City+++Page+062+++Section+015+2++Section+022+++Part/Spokane+County+1912/Washington/ In the southern section, it calls for running "Durand Road" and "Finch Road" up the side of a 30-foot cliff. I guarantee those two roads have never been built. |
| 70672286 | over 6 years ago | This edit appears to have left a gap in the Milk River when you deleted way/95334308. Was this intentional? |
| 70674522 | over 6 years ago | There's a specific ban on bicycles on I-90 heading eastward from the Geiger junction near Airway Heights, but I don't know how far east it extends. |
| 70526667 | over 6 years ago | I'm aware that it's not freeform, but I'd expect someone fixing these by hand to spot mistakes such as using the "|" character instead of a semicolon, or entering "10:30a-17:00" instead of "10:30-17:00". |
| 70526667 | over 6 years ago | Are you doing an automated conversion here? I'm seeing a number of "opening_hours:rubbish" on things that are quite human-readable. |
| 70514343 | over 6 years ago | Is the Selway Lodge runway still in use? All available imagery shows an "X" at the north end indicating permanent closure. |
| 70354446 | over 6 years ago | It looks like you forgot to add the "building" tag to the building you drew. |
| 69958417 | over 6 years ago | For the Sammamish situation, the original mapping was done from imagery (Mapbox Satellite) showing halfway-finished construction. JustinOMeara then added buildings traced from pre-construction imagery (Bing). I was subsequently able to verify that Esri imagery was post-construction, and re-mapped the area from that. The Sammamish area is messy: it's three buildings built into the side of a steep hill, with ground-level parking lots on the roofs of two of those buildings. If you're not paying attention to things like impossible shadows, it looks like three parking lots and four buildings. |
| 70212750 | over 6 years ago | Those two points were what are known as "address nodes": points that give the location of an address. I've restored them. |
| 69865811 | over 6 years ago | Okay, I've restored the apartments. |
| 70162256 | over 6 years ago | When you're editing in Spokane County, please use the "Esri World Imagery" layer. It's the newest available, where "Esri Clarity", at least at most zoom levels, is the oldest. |
| 70165015 | over 6 years ago | A quick spot-check says that most if not all of them are Maps.Me bookmarks. Probably the best thing to do is just revert the entire changeset. |