Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 61622278 | over 7 years ago | Where are you getting the route of this railroad from? I'm not seeing evidence of it in the aerial imagery, and neither the 1903, 1961, nor 1987 USGS topo maps of the area show it. |
| 61484899 | over 7 years ago | Where are you getting the name "3I" from? Looking at historic topo maps, it appears to be "state highway 31", and I can't find a reference to it that's less than 68 years old. |
| 61205111 | over 7 years ago | Where are you getting that this has a traffic signal? It was a four-way stop when I drove through a few weeks ago, and I haven't heard of any construction since. |
| 61181396 | over 7 years ago | Where are you getting the street layout of Tecomate from? It doesn't show up on any of the aerial imagery. |
| 61153017 | over 7 years ago | Don't vandalize the map. |
| 61101492 | over 7 years ago | Please stop making changes based on outdated maps. Inland Empire south of 23rd hasn't been an arterial since it was cut off from US-195. |
| 61100948 | over 7 years ago | Maxwell between Washington and Ash was re-engineered earlier this year in a way that's significantly reducing the traffic flow. |
| 60941579 | over 7 years ago | Are you sure this is a state park? The Flathead County Parks website lists it as a county park: https://flathead.mt.gov/parks_rec/parks.php |
| 60885946 | over 7 years ago | The "Salmon River" relation you created has a waterway type of "LowerSalmon", which isn't a valid type, it includes a seemingly arbitrary part of the Snake River, and it excludes a similarly-arbitrary part of the Salmon River. |
| 60885946 | over 7 years ago | I'm not sure what you were trying to do here, but I don't think it worked. |
| 60881449 | over 7 years ago | Drawing one thing on top of another like you've done here doesn't work very well. If you want to indicate that "Cosway Road" permits foot traffic, you should select it and set the "foot" allowed-access field to "yes". If instead there's a trail running parallel to "Cosway Road", carefully draw it parallel to the road, only intersecting at the ends. |
| 60739729 | over 7 years ago | If you're going to be editing in Spokane County, please use Esri World Imagery. It's considerably newer, sharper, and better-aligned than Mapbox Satellite. |
| 60692332 | over 7 years ago | You might want to read osm.wiki/Relations/Relations_are_not_Categories -- "Spokane County Highway Bike Routes" seems like a textbook example of what relations should not be used for. |
| 60646750 | over 7 years ago | When I'm mapping buildings, I'll flip back and forth between the clearest available imagery (usually Esri Clarity, but sometimes Esri World) and the newest available imagery (usually DigitalGlobe Standard). I might also bring in a third image option if it's got useful shadows (eg. for telling if something is a flat-roofed building or a ground-level feature). |
| 60646750 | over 7 years ago | I noticed it at the intersection of "County Road" and "D Street": changeset/60646750#map=19/45.93509/-116.12952 The five smallest building outlines there look more like utility trailers than buildings. |
| 60646750 | over 7 years ago | You appear to have traced a half-dozen utility trailers here, in addition to the buildings. |
| 60622546 | over 7 years ago | Normally, a large river such as the Stillwater or the Flathead is mapped in two parts: an area or multipolygon tracing the banks, and a line down the middle following the path of greatest flow. The "River" tag and the name of the river go on the the central line, while the outer edge is tagged as "Riverbank". It looks like whoever added the Stillwater didn't do the second part: the central line for the Stillwater ends right where he started adding the riverbank. |
| 60622027 | over 7 years ago | The usual tags for the roads in/accessing a parking lot are "Parking aisle", "Driveway", or if you're not sure how to classify it, the generic "Service road". |
| 60583195 | over 7 years ago | This looks like it's a switching/transformer facility rather than a power-generating facility. The usual way to map these in OSM is to trace the fence line and tag it as "Substation", which I've done. (If I've missed something and there's a gas turbine or the like in there, feel free to change it back.) |
| 60557743 | over 7 years ago | If you're having trouble telling what shape a building is, please switch background imagery (the third or fourth button from the top on the right-hand side, the one that looks sort of like three stacked sheets of paper). What you've drawn here looks almost nothing like how the building appears in Esri Clarity, or Mapbox Satellite, or really anything except Bing Imagery. |