OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
111655675 about 4 years ago

I've reverted this changeset. Just like last time, the things you deleted were correctly labeled as private driveways.

111620799 about 4 years ago

Two of the three things you deleted were marked as "private driveway", not "road". The correct thing to do would have been to mark the third one as a private driveway as well.

111565056 about 4 years ago

The "description" field is intended for information that doesn't fit in the structured tags, such as what sort of real estate services are offered. It's not a place to write a promotional blurb for your business.

111519037 about 4 years ago

Three errors:

1) Removal of "building=apartments" tags from two buildings.
2) Mapping four buildings as one.
3) A building outline is about 25% larger than the building.

111518966 about 4 years ago

Three errors:

1) A building missing a quarter of its outline.
2) Two buildings mapped as one.
3) Three buildings mapped as one.

111518984 about 4 years ago

Two errors:

1) A building missing a corner
2) Two buildings mapped as one.

111518010 about 4 years ago

When used carefully, inspecting each candidate building against appropriate imagery to ensure that it (1) exists and (2) is traced properly, RapID is an accepted tool.

When using it as you are, importing buildings at rates in excess of one per second, it falls solidly under the import guidelines.

And shifting the burden of error checking onto me is unacceptable. It takes about five minutes to inspect each changeset, or longer if I need to fix anything. The 600 or so changesets you've made in the past day will take me about a month to review if everything is perfect; given the number of errors I've found so far, three to four months is a more reasonable estimate.

111518010 about 4 years ago

Please read osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines and the rest of osm.wiki/Category:Import_Policy -- the standard for imports is "guilty until proven innocent".

I'd prefer not to revert it myself -- the Data Working Group has better tools and more experience than I do.

111518010 about 4 years ago

The change I feel necessary is to revert everything you've done since changeset #111471825 as an undiscussed import. Do you agree?

111518275 about 4 years ago

Which renderer are you using that is so incredibly broken that it ignores some building types?

The correct thing to do is to fix the renderer, not break the map.

111518275 about 4 years ago

Is there a reason why you think that Maplewood Gardens, The Academy, Altura, and The Highline shouldn't be apartment buildings, or is it just that RapID is allergic to classifying building types?

111518010 about 4 years ago

You're clearly not spending enough, if any, time reviewing things. One of the "buildings" in this changeset is a travel trailer, and another only vaguely resembles the actual structure on the ground.

Please stop.

111516961 about 4 years ago

Please stop adding low-quality scribbles to the map.

111516159 about 4 years ago

Please don't. We're supposed to be getting a much better set of building outlines to import from in the near future.

110887834 over 4 years ago

What sort of a business is a "Chris O'Doherty - Windermere"? It's useful to tag that so people can find it when searching by type, not just when searching by name.

110258620 over 4 years ago

It would be nice if you explained *why* you're changing the road classification. The last person to do so did.

109971441 over 4 years ago

You've changed the official name of the United States to "ur=ریاست ہائے متحدہ". Do you plan to fix this?

108863021 over 4 years ago

What sort of a thing is "Pandora"? I'm pretty sure that "park" isn't the correct tag for it.

108518791 over 4 years ago

I've noticed a few errors in this changeset:

* Where southbound Ash Street divides in two, both sides of the split are roads, and both of them go by the name "Ash Street".
* There's a similar issue where southbound Maple Street comes off the bridge: both pieces prior to the merge are roads known as "Maple Street".
* 4th Avenue west of Maple isn't an arterial: the speed limit is 25 mph and cross streets don't have stop signs. This means it should be tagged as "unclassified", not "tertiary".

I'm also not sure the classification of Sprague Way is correct: yes, it's the primary connection between two major streets, but it is not itself a major street.

107407270 over 4 years ago

Really damn minor state route.