Carnildo's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 94783150 | about 5 years ago | Passes are fuzzy areas, typically considered to be everything between the two nearest high points or false summits. OSM's got the "mountain pass" key (mountain_pass=*) for the high point where a highway goes through one. Sometimes this corresponds to the saddle point, sometimes it doesn't. |
| 94783150 | about 5 years ago | Just checked a second one, and from the aerial imagery and topo maps, it looks like Expedition Pass Trail runs along the side of the Expedition Pass saddle. |
| 94783150 | about 5 years ago | I don't think this is correct. I don't know about any of the others, but the saddle point at Kingman Pass is somewhere in the bed of Glen Creek, not on the road. |
| 94558076 | about 5 years ago | Please stop using RapiD for mapping. By my count, you're currently running slightly under 90% accuracy when adding buildings, which just isn't good enough, particularly when you're making mistakes such as adding round buildings as square ones. |
| 94533554 | about 5 years ago | Please pay attention to what the AI is telling you to do. For example, in this changeset, you tagged three sets of bleachers as two buildings. |
| 94529339 | about 5 years ago | When you're adding these buildings, please check against the latest imagery. For Spokane County, NAIP is currently the latest, while in urban areas, Bing is only a few weeks older and much sharper. It looks like RapiD is using Esri Clarity, which is usually the oldest. |
| 94397823 | about 5 years ago | I use the history tab on the OSM site, zoomed to give me a view of Eastern Washington/Northern Idaho/Western Montana. Another popular option is OSMCha (https://osmcha.org/), which has all sorts of filtering options. |
| 94401820 | about 5 years ago | I don't think the entire area is a single building. You probably want to use the "apartment complex" tag here. |
| 94400795 | about 5 years ago | "North Pole, Alaska" is a real place, and it's not unreasonable to expect it to have a church: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_Pole,_Alaska |
| 94397823 | about 5 years ago | Thanks for clearing up those fixmes. Fields Spring is about a five-hour round trip for me, so it's not somewhere I get to very often. |
| 94398050 | about 5 years ago | Why did you delete South 118th Street? Aerial imagery shows something reasonably street-like in that location. |
| 94298929 | about 5 years ago | You appear to have tagged a number of electric poles as "power=line" rather than "power=pole" or "power=tower". |
| 94258931 | about 5 years ago | Where are you getting this service road from? It's not in any of the imagery, and I don't recall one in the area from the last time I visited. |
| 93030929 | about 5 years ago | I've reverted the deletion. |
| 94047468 | about 5 years ago | It's not a track just because it's in a forest. Most of these appear to be badly-mapped driveways or residential roads. |
| 93957954 | about 5 years ago | Are you sure this name is correct? Everything I can find says that the old name was the correct one. |
| 93955999 | about 5 years ago | When you're dividing a road like you did here, make sure you update the information on that road. Before I fixed it, the southern half of Francis was labeled as being five lanes wide with lanes running both directions despite being a one-way road, while the northern half didn't even have a speed limit. |
| 93884420 | about 5 years ago | Is there a reason why you disconnected the path leading to a boat launch from the boat launch itself? |
| 93814576 | about 5 years ago | Negative layer numbers are traditionally used for underground objects. If the editor is warning you about a sidewalk crossing a roof-only building, the correct fix is to put the roof on layer 1, not to put the sidewalk on layer -1. |
| 93759468 | about 5 years ago | As far as I can tell, the "car wash" you added is a defunct car wash with a building still prominently labeled "Car Wash" with an equally prominent "Car Wash" sign out front. |