CRCulver's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 158807587 | about 1 year ago | Please stop changing highway=path ways to highway=cycleway when there is standard European Union signage showing that the way is for both bikes and pedestrians. According to the OSM wiki, highway=path is the matching tagging for this signage: |
| 157862455 | about 1 year ago | I saw that, but clicking on path=crossing there brings one to the highway=path article, where there is no description of such a tag. That is what I mean by undocumented, this tag seems ad hoc and real-world usage in tools is low. Moreover, the footway=crossing tag on the English wiki says that it is widely used for highway=path, and this was carried over as a recommendation into the PL wiki. |
| 157862455 | about 1 year ago | Your same link recommends footway=crossing. In any event, this tag is not documented at the English wiki, and OSM is a global project where mappers may be editing Poland in addition to numerous other countries, and therefore should not be expected to know Polish conventions described only in Polish. |
| 157862455 | about 1 year ago | Why did you replace footway=crossing here with path=crossing? Per wiki, footway=crossing is widely used in these highway=path contexts (including in Poland specifically), while path=crossing doesn't even seem to be documented. |
| 134414841 | about 1 year ago | Sorry, that should have been: “and the repeat_on= tag will specify that the *area* spans two floors.” |
| 134414841 | about 1 year ago | The duplicated H&M shop at Promenada mall will strike many map consumers as an error; there is only a single H&M shop here that spans two floors. Might you consider fixing this by e.g. specifying level=0;1 for the shop, and mapping it separately from the indoor=room? I have already fixed the nearby Intersport shop in changeset/157730892. There, because the two floors have identical room dimensions, both the room and the shop only need to be tagged once and the repeat_on= tag will specify that the way spans two floors. |
| 150390996 | about 1 year ago | What is the source of these highway=motorway_junction tags all over Kyrgyzstan? I have not been able to verify any of these tags during on-the-ground surveys, and it is not common practice in the region to add them to trunk roads and primary highways. |
| 135598725 | about 1 year ago | Please do not add wild camping spots to OSM. The tourism=camp_site tag on OSM is only for campsites that are somehow official. |
| 46139341 | about 1 year ago | Why did you add denomination=sunni to sites in the Pamir region of Tajikistan? The people here follow the Nizari Ismaili denomination of Islam (i.e. denomination=shia). |
| 153348458 | over 1 year ago | You can do an Overpass API query for name:en tags in areas you have mapped. |
| 153348458 | over 1 year ago | English uses title case for street names, so "Abdi bobo street" should have been instead "Abdi Bobo Street". Please fix this error in all of the name:en tags you have created for streets in Uzbekistan. |
| 155488681 | over 1 year ago | direction=both is redundant on a stop sign node when the node is at the intersection and stop=all is already present. The only place I have seen direction=both also added is the LA metropolitan area. |
| 124029197 | over 1 year ago | Please do not add to houses the names of the families resident therein. |
| 74771069 | over 1 year ago | You added a trail at coordinates 37.4323147, 73.1036590 with the name= tag "Steep Trail". In Tajikistan, name= tags should be in Tajik, not in English. Does this trail have an official name? If no, the name= tag should be deleted. If you want to express the steepness of the trail, then difficulty or incline tags are a more appropriate way to do that. |
| 154876625 | over 1 year ago | If you do not explain your edits and match the facts on the ground, I will continue to revert your Samarkand changesets and escalate this matter to the Data Working Group. I see that you were already blocked in the past for writing only “исправление ошибок” as your changeset comment. |
| 153599098 | over 1 year ago | Please stop changing name= tags that I created on the basis of an on-the-ground survey, as when you changed the Uzbek-language name= tags of Samarkand's central parks back to English-language names. Name= tags for such public infastructure countries are in the local language, with English names specified in name:en= tags. Your changeset comments "исправление ошибок" are dishonest. If you do not cease this destructive editing, I will have to escalate this situation to the Data Working Group. |
| 153333465 | over 1 year ago | This is a standard found across the world, and there is no need for Uzbekistan to be different. |
| 153601252 | over 1 year ago | You restored spurious name tags to the park along Universitet bulvari in Samarkand: I have deleted them again in changeset/153687537. For one, name= tags in Uzbekistan should be the Uzbek-language name, not English ones. Secondly, while I did a personal survey of this area, I was unable to verify that the park itself (as opposed to the surrounding road) has any such name. |
| 153333465 | over 1 year ago | Did you make a mistake? There is no text from you here, only my quoted changeset comment. |
| 153159867 | over 1 year ago | I have remapped this portion of Registon ko'chasi correctly in changeset/153333465. |