Generally speaking where I downgraded it, I did so because it doesn't qualify as a motorway, because of intervening or terminating at-grade intersections, or it was an iffy call and it's better to go with the lower value to avoid level creep on edge cases.

Could you be more specific?

Sorry, US 54.

Feeling like US 50 is a little overrated as a trunk; that value tends to be used as an indication that something's almost but not quite a motorway, not a two lane federal highway. Compare US 69 in Oklahoma.

Feeling like US 50 is a little overrated as a trunk; that value tends to be used as an indication that something's almost but not quite a motorway, not a two lane federal highway. Compare US 69 in Oklahoma.

This should probably get punted to talk-us, not the wiki.

So that'd be ref=NF 1828-118, and noname=yes, with no name.

The US tagging page is not correct or consistent in this case.

Yeah, that's wrong. This is more applicable to the situation.

osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only

Well, that would be ref=NF 44, not name=Forest Road 44. Refs are not names.

I can also confirm that Camp Baldwin, which is within the national forest on 44, from survey, is 76201 Dufur Valley Road.

name=Dufur Valley Road is correct. The ref=* value should not be in name or alt_name at all.

C'mon, buddy, that note is disputable and capricious at best. Let's have a little decorum instead of flag planting, eh?

It was actually already there before but under the boundary=protected_area protect_class=24 scheme, which it was suggested that I update. I literally woke up to that ruling this morning. I suspect Oklahoma is now much smaller with three exclaves (the Pawnee triangle near Tulsa, the southwest corner and Fort Sill's c1890 boundary), but not entirely sure yet.

Seems like we've been going back and forth on this for about a decade but looks like aboriginal_lands is more or less winning out. Changed it.

Can't use Google Maps for this, that violates both OSM and Google's licenses.

Likewise, looks like the motorways themselves were moved without any regard to the placement, lanes or turn lanes tagging...took quite a bit of work to straighten that out.

I'm curious where you're getting Crossroads of America, Crosstown Expressway and Tinker Diagonal from... those freeways were renamed years ago and have signs up, and ODOT commonly refers to that interchange as Dallas Junction.

Yeah, nationally, in the US, trunk is expressway. It's really hard to argue that 33 is more than a secondary on either end of this expressway, or that this isn't an expressway.

highway=trunk is for surface expressways (ie, freeways that are not grade seperated) and single-carriageway freeways (one road, no intersections).

South Walnut Avenue works better than S. Walnut Ave. because computers have a hard time expanding abbreviations but can easily create abbreviations if desired.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/86472516

No abbreviations in names and addresses, please.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/86472542

Easily done. Instead of mapping it as a single golf course, map both golf courses separately and then add both to a single site relation. osm.wiki/Relation:site