BCNorwich's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 146506651 | almost 2 years ago | Fiction removed. |
| 146506107 | almost 2 years ago | Fictional motorways removed. |
| 146505700 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, I've removed your fictional motorways and wetlands. Your buildings would look better if they were squared up. |
| 146506314 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, Welcome to OpenStreetMap. Can you please say why you've removed these footpaths? They are in the most part visible in available imagery. Regards Bernard. |
| 146470150 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You duplicated some highways by placing new roads on top of existing roads. If a road needs correcting it's OSM practice to correct the existing road. I've now removed the duplicates that disrupted routing. I also added the road names. Regards Bernard. |
| 146475930 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You duplicated a highway by mapping a new footpath partly on top of an existing service road. I've removed the duplicated highway and amended the section of the service road to reflect PRoW status. Regards Bernard. |
| 146246524 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You somehow duplicated several roads here, I've removed the duplicated sections. Regards Bernard. |
| 146205324 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You duplicated the Matteke-Rasulpur Tarar Road. OSM practice is to correct existing features not just map over them as this practice disrupts routing. I've removed the duplications and placed the name tag on the existing highways. Regards Bernard. |
| 146158572 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You duplicated some sections of the highway by placing some of the footpath on top of existing highways. This disrupts routing. It's OSM practice to amend the existing features rather than mapping on top of or removing them. I've removed the duplicate sections and amended the existing highways. Regards Bernard. |
| 145993591 | almost 2 years ago | No response so I've removed all the duplicate tracks. |
| 146097895 | almost 2 years ago | Duplicated highway removed, name added to the existing highway |
| 146079633 | almost 2 years ago | Duplicated highway removed. |
| 145993724 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, Most of these ways look like field boundary lines rather than tracks. If they are tracks then you have duplicated some sections of them. So are they really highways or are they field edges? Regards Bernard. |
| 146081276 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You've actually made duplicate highways by mapping the raceway on top of existing highways which disrupts routing. I've removed the duplicated highways and created a route relation for the raceway. Regards Bernard. |
| 146107059 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, Welcome to OpenStreetMap. Thanks for adding your new speed data. Unfortunately, it went a bit wrong and you added a new highway atop the existing highway. Your thinking was correct, the existing highway should be split and the new section speed tag amended. I was able to figure out what you wanted to do and made the amendments, (OSM practice is to make corrections to existing features where possible to maintain history). Please check that I've got the position of the 30 limit placed correctly. Regards Bernard. |
| 146106913 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, Welcome to OpenStreetMap. In changing the road name you somehow duplicated the highway which disrupts routing. So I've removed the duplication. I checked the name and it seems Holly Hill is correct. So the name should not be changed. Regards Bernard. |
| 146034120 | almost 2 years ago | Hello, Thanks for responding. A local street or any street is classed as a highway. Please see here:- highway=* The page explains that everything from a motorway to an unpaved path is a highway. Anyway my point was to inform you of the problems with duplicating highways. Also OSM's best practice of correcting existing features instead of mapping over them. If you need any help or further clarification please just ask. Regards Bernard. |
| 146034120 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, You've mapped lots of your new highways on top of existing highways. This disrupts routing so I've removed all the duplicated sections. If a highway needs amending it's OSM practice to do this to the existing highway, thus maintaining OSM history. Regards Bernard. |
| 145993591 | almost 2 years ago | Hello and Welcome to OpenStreetMap. These many tracks you've added are actually mostly field boundaries. You can see the lines of agricultural vehicle tracks on some imagery which go across these fields, no along the tracks you've drawn. The best imagery for clarity is Esri World Imagery which you can open in the iD editor. What drew me to look at these tracks is the fact that a lot of sections are duplicated. Could you map these features as landuse=farmland and survey to determine which lines are truly highways? Regards Bernard. |
| 145898212 | almost 2 years ago | Hi, Welcome to OpenStreetMap. The track you removed was the service road and access to the Scout Hall. Can you state please, how the hall is now accessed? Regards Bernard. |