OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
133300414 almost 3 years ago

Hi ZuquetuPlexis,
I work here and I dont understand your changes. Why you removed the building-tags of buildings? Why you add college tags to them? There is 1 college "TH Wildau" and it is made of many buildings (some called Haus some Halle). If something is made of stone and has windows, and is made for people.
I read OSM wiki here:
building=*
1. "Haus 13" = building office,
2. Haus15 + Halle* = building=college, cite from wiki "Use amenity=college on the whole college area to represent the college as an institution." (this is meant once for the area) see wiki below.
Also here it is clearly mentioned!
building=college
As we rely on these data and have software based on official OSM-wiki, I need to change this back soon.
Please comment on this.
Kind regards, A.

132197649 almost 3 years ago

Hello,
I simply wanted to remove >100x wikipedia=http..., so I moved the Wikipedia-Tag into a common relation. But I also wondered about the need for this wiki-tag. I'm fine with the removal, but I was carefull, because I once read the rule: "respect the work of others" which caused my decision. I should have added a fixme.
Kind regards, Alex

131570467 almost 3 years ago

sorry, wrong comment: should be "fix typo"

130312723 about 3 years ago

Hi MRFahruddin,
please read this:
wikipedia=*#Examples

wikipedia = "id:Abcd" not "http.."
Could you fix your recent edits? (about 10)

Thanks, Alex

128734430 about 3 years ago

Hi Movses,
you set type="" for
relation/14869034
Could you check this again?
Thx Alex

128987811 about 3 years ago

Sorry wrong comment, should be:
fix typo in key

128395067 about 3 years ago

Hi Jeffrey Edamer,
please read this:
wikipedia=*
wikipedia=lang:Abcd, not =http..
Thx, Alex

127027039 about 3 years ago

Hallo B.,
warum änderst du die wikipedia-tags ab, gegen die Anleitung hier?
osm.wiki/DE:Key:wikipedia
MfG, A.

114216172 over 3 years ago

Hallo Polarbear, das tut mir leid. Aus meiner Sicht sollten problematische Zeichen raus aus allen Tags. Vor weinigen Jahren gab es z.B. tausende Tags mit einem (unsichtbaren!) 0x7F Zeichen drin. Der Name sah gut aus, war aber daruch nirgends auffindbar (via verschiedene Suchfunktionen (egal ob APIs oder Website). Und einige Zeichen führten zu einem Updatestop auf taginfo.openstreetmap.org.
Daher würde ich schon sagen, dass einige Zeichen zumindest fragwürdig wenn nicht gar problematisch sind. Ich hoffe du nimmst mir dies nicht übel.
MfG, Alexander

125911616 over 3 years ago

Hi Mike Bosschaert,
you added 3 buildings with empty amenity= tag. Could you check this?
Thanks, Alex

124569199 over 3 years ago

Hi clementader, please follow wikipedia=*#Examples
wikipedia="fr:Abcd", not ="http.."
Thanks, Alex

123862427 over 3 years ago

Hi David,
please check again your changes:
relation/2339610/history
Thanks, Alex

123892045 over 3 years ago

Hi PasqualeD,
please follow this wiki-page:
wikipedia=*#Examples
Short: wikipedia=it:Name, not =http..
Thanks, Alex

122941126 over 3 years ago

Hi Gaessje, bitte lies
osm.wiki/DE:Key:wikipedia?uselang=de#Bevorzugtes_Tagging
wikipedia=de:Abcd, nicht http...
Danke, Alex

122703565 over 3 years ago

Hi Toni, many services require relations:
wikidata.org, polygons.openstreetmap.fr,
and even JOSM Ctrl+I shows area only for relations, not ways.
Therefore to say it does not make sense is unfair. But I agree with the double tags. And can remove them, after we agreed on proceeding.
KR Alex

121964497 over 3 years ago

Hi Hartmut,
please check again
way/1066864272
I found it in here:
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/reports/characters_in_keys#problem
Thanks, Alex

120855960 over 3 years ago

Hi tyler,
please follow wikipedia=*#Examples
not writing wikipedia=http...
Thx, Alex

120540425 over 3 years ago

Hi JohnGoodBreed,
please read this:
wikipedia=*#Examples
wikipedia = lang:Abc, not http...
Thx, Alex

120331544 over 3 years ago

Hi hogrod,
could you please consider writing: wikipedia=en:Abcd (not using https:), see
wikipedia=*#Examples
Thanks, Alex

119545650 over 3 years ago

Hi cOSMografix,
please read this:
osm.wiki/FR:Key:wikipedia#Syntaxe
Merci, Alex